Now, Trump is urging the judge to let the defamation proceedings remain on track because he claims the Wall Street Journal has been unsuccessful in proving the card he allegedly sent to Epstein was real.
An identical birthday note handed over to the House Oversight Committee by the Epstein estate does not prove that Trump actually wrote and sent the letter, according to a new filing by Trump’s lawyers.
They have also accused the Wall Street Journal of “[prioritising] gossip, clicks, and profit over truth”.
The Murdochs are standing by the accuracy of the story and there is plenty at stake for both titans. For Murdoch and his marque publication there is as much as US$10 billion ($15.3 billion) on the line, as well as credibility and journalistic reputation.
For Trump, who has been accused by his own fan base of being opaque around his relationship with Epstein, the Wall Street Journal’s story leaves him vulnerable to fresh allegations. His attempts to deflect or dismiss it have failed, and he has at times lashed out at his own base for their fixation on the story.
Neither of the titans seem prepared to let it go.
While the Murdoch camp clearly wants the defamation action by Trump to be dropped, he seems prepared to back the publication’s journalistic integrity given there is no hint of a settlement in the wings.
Loading
And Murdoch should take some comfort in a US federal judge recently dismissing Trump’s separate $15 billion defamation case against The New York Times, citing deficiencies in its legal foundation.
US District Judge Steven Merryday ruled that Trump had failed to comply with a federal requirement demanding a “short and plain statement” justifying his claim for relief. The court observed that a legal filing is not “a protected platform to rage against an adversary”.
Trump has since refiled that claim. He is clearly prepared to take on the courts and the behemoths of the fourth estate, egged on by his entourage of sycophants pumping up his tyres at every step.
Murdoch is not the sort to pay homage lightly, and at 94, the mogul seems ready and willing to take Trump on.
The Business Briefing newsletter delivers major stories, exclusive coverage and expert opinion. Sign up to get it every weekday morning.
