Hugh MacDonald’s top 50 sports books of all time: The power and the glory, the passion and the pain… and the richest tales that fiction can only aspire to

Newspapers in Britain once had an uneasy relationship with sport. The editorial part of the office that dealt with balls, rackets and an assortment of sticks was called the toy department.
This was never the case in the USA. Newspapers there knew that sport brought in the readers and that the best writers should and could be deployed there.
The American publishing industry, too, found out that sports books could be frank, honest, funny, informative and, yes, talk to the human condition. Best of all, they sold.
It took some time for us to catch up. Slowly, sports desks gained an appreciation. There had always been talented people designing and writing the pages, not least such as Ian Wooldridge of this parish. But popularity could now be measured in clicks. Sport, too, was recognised as more than the working-class ballet.
The precise date for this to occur in the British publishing industry can be debated. Some will argue that Fever Pitch (1992) was the breakthrough, proving that a football novel could be both admired and commercially successful. This reader demurs. Nick Hornby’s book is as much a football novel as The Catcher in the Rye is a farming saga.
I would date the great British sports book revolution to the publication of Only a Game? The Diary of a Professional Footballer some 40 years ago. Eamon Dunphy’s ground-breaking tale did not create new sales records. But everyone who read it knew that it heralded a new ball game.
Eamon Dunphy’s Only A Game was a pioneering effort which brought a new outlook on football
There was a place now for honest, raw and challenging books about sport. They could be written by players, commentators or fans. But they had to contain more than cliches or vapid views. GB had caught up with the USA.
My passion for sports books was initially fed by imports from across the water but there was now a vibrant alternative on this side of the pond. It has only gained strength in the decades since Only a Game?
The world of sport is a genre that covers all disciplines and can even introduce one to a new passion. My love for baseball derived from a love of books, namely from the work of David Halberstam and Roger Kahn. My fascination with cycling as a sport came from watching Robert Millar and, crucially, reading about him. Wooldridge, Michael Parkinson, Peter Dobereiner, James Lawton and, of course, Hugh McIlvanney entertained me in newspapers and then in books.
The scope of the sports book encompassed the world. It covered field, pitch, track, table, ring and court. It told of the humble, the tragic, the brave and the defiant. And many more. It was wonderful, entertaining and more readily available.
This list of best sports books carries a series of caveats.
First, such a list can only be subjective.
Second, there are notable omissions and, inevitably, I’ll have left at least one book out that should be on the list. Readers will remind me of that, no doubt.
Third, there have to be some ground rules. I decided to avoid fiction. Fever Pitch is thus out but so are The Natural (Bernard Malamud), The Great American Novel (Philip Roth), Fat City (Leonard Gardner) and Rope Burns: Stories From The Corner (F.X. Toole). But faction, a blend of fiction and real-life events, survives the cut.
Fourth, ‘other people’s favourites’ is not a category. They can make their own list. For example, The Miracle of Castel di Sangro by Joe McGinniss has ardent followers. Not me. I appreciate his writing but he was more assured and informative in The Selling of the President. AJ Liebling, too, does not break the top 50 though he is an influential writer on boxing. I believe there are better, more challenging books on the fight game.
Daily Mail Sport’s Hugh MacDonald has carefully curated his top 50 finest sporting reads
There are obvious problems, too, in drawing up the list. How to allocate across all sports? Should there be more women on the list? Is it right to have the same amount of cricket books as baseball books in a list in a British paper? Is it right, as I have done, to avoid choosing the work of colleagues on this newspaper?
The questions go on and there can only be one answer. This is a list compiled by one person. It is thus biased, flawed and incomplete. This isn’t an apology but an admission of guilt.
However, it may lead one reader to just one book that he or she enjoys. In that, it will have served its purpose. It may also solve a Christmas problem in those last days of desperation.
It will also cause arguments, most of them concerning the precise incompetence of this writer. It was ever thus. It is not always fun and games in the toy department.
READ MORE: Click here for Hugh’s Top 50 Sports Books… and get in touch to let us know YOUR favourites.
