Why these Sydney restaurants lost their coveted hats – including The Gidley famed for serving one of the world’s best burgers

Every year, mystery diners put restaurants to the test, awarding coveted hats to the standout dining venues – much like the world-renowned Michelin stars.
The Good Food Guide introduced its chefs’ hat rating system 42 years ago, with anonymous critics assessing restaurants on their food, service, value for money and overall dining experience.
For the 2027 awards, around 160 restaurants across NSW earned at least one hat after inspectors spent six months quietly dining at more than 500 venues.
Each restaurant reviewed in the Guide is given a score out of 20. Restaurants scoring 15 points earn one hat, those receiving 16 or 17 are awarded two hats, while those with marks between 18 and 20 earn three hats.
While many retained their hats or earned another, 13 Sydney restaurants – including one famed for having the world’s ninth-best burger – lost their prestigious ratings.
In an unexpected twist, popular CBD restaurants The Gidley, Loulou Bistro Martin Place and The Star’s Sokyo were all stripped of their highly regarded one-hat ratings.
According to Good Food Guide national restaurant editor Callan Boys, critics are strictly instructed to remain anonymous during visits to ensure their dining experience reflects that of an everyday customer.
Poor service was the main reason restaurants lost their hats, with Callan saying it was the ‘greatest contributing factor to declining scores this year’.
The Gidley, a popular steakhouse hidden beneath the streets of Sydney’s CBD, has been stripped of its one-hat rating
The opulent fine-dining steakhouse is renowned for serving some of the world’s best steaks and burgers
‘In one instance, a solo reviewer was mostly ignored in favour of the bigger tables of blokes ordering triple-digit bottles,’ Callan said.
‘Plates weren’t refreshed, empty glasses were not refilled or removed, and staff offered little guidance… That restaurant no longer has a hat.
‘We understand that it’s important to look after the big-spender tables, but we also want to celebrate restaurants with staff trained to see a solo diner and think, “Right, I’m going to make sure this person eating alone has the best night possible.”
‘This is what real hospitality looks like.’
One of the most surprising demotions is The Gidley, an opulent fine-dining steakhouse renowned for serving some of the world’s best steaks and burgers.
In 2024, the restaurant’s cheeseburger was ranked the ninth best burger in the world by World’s 101 Best Steak Restaurants and crowned number one in Australia.
Hidden beneath the streets of Sydney’s CBD, the restaurant has become a popular dining destination, with reservations booked out weeks in advance.
It also has a strict no-phone policy in the main dining area, meaning guests are banned from taking pictures of their meals so they can remain present and enjoy the experience.
Sokyo, one of Sydney’s most popular contemporary Japanese restaurants, was quietly removed from the one-hatted list of 2027.
Sokyo, one of Sydney’s most popular contemporary Japanese restaurants, was quietly removed from the one-hatted list
Loulou Bistro Martin Place is a modern French restaurant serving up popular dishes such as steak frites, escargots, beef tartare and duck. However, the bistro appears to have missed the mark after losing its one hat rating
The restaurant, located inside The Star, uses traditional sushi and sashimi techniques with Australian meats and seafood – including Moreton Bay bugs and tuna.
Sokyo, which opened in 2011, retained its one-hat rating for most years between 2013 and 2026, so losing its 2027 title has come as a surprise to many.
Loulou Bistro Martin Place is a modern French restaurant serving up popular dishes such as steak frites, escargots, beef tartare and duck.
Shortly after opening in July 2025, the restaurant was awarded a one-hat rating.
However, the bistro has failed to retain its 2027 accolade.
