How England cracked down on being ‘the world’s least-disciplined team’: Why they brought a Test referee into training, players’ ratings for penalty probability and what they’ve changed since summer sin-bin woes

The referee’s whistle has been one of England’s most valuable weapons this autumn. On the evidence of the opening two rounds of the November Tests, Steve Borthwick’s side seem to have finally tightened up their discipline.
Since the summer, their penalty count has dropped from 11.25 per game – the highest in the world in 2026 – to seven. And bar Luke Cowan-Dickie’s late yellow card against Japan, they have managed to keep 15 players on the pitch, having conceded six yellows in their three Nations Championship matches during the summer. Only Argentina (nine) have more over the first five rounds of the tournament.
So, what is the secret? This autumn, PREM Rugby and international referee Christophe Ridley has spent more time in camp with the team on an unpaid arrangement. Almost every live training session has been officiated to Test match standards.
Players focus on tackle height, the offside line and rolling out of the tackle before being given a percentage score at the end of each session.
‘We would break up into small groups and had good conversations in and around that,’ said hooker Jamie George. ‘They were very open. There was one coach per group. For example Henry Pollock was in my group – when does he feel like he gives away penalties? Why does he feel that way? It’s about stressing the importance of what we can do around him to make sure he’s not put into those positions.’
Daily Mail Sport understands there would be appetite for England to bring in a full-time refereeing coach at some point in the future, similar to the French and South African arrangements with Jerome Garces and Jaco Peyper. Wales have done similar with Ben Whitehouse.
Henry Arundell received two yellow cards in quick succession against Scotland in the Six Nations, first for sealing off a ruck (left), then for tackling Kyle Steyn in the air (right)
PREM and international referee Christophe Ridley (right) has been invited into England camp to officiate training matches
Your browser does not support iframes.
‘I think a referee going in can definitely help you and get you into good habits,’ legendary Welsh referee Nigel Owens, who took charge of 100 Tests before retiring in 2020, told Daily Mail Sport.
‘A couple of players would come to me and say, “I’m struggling with referees at the moment” or “I’m finding it difficult to communicate with them in the heat of the moment”. I’d ask them to send me a couple of clips or examples.
‘I’d tell them to approach it in a different way, or little things like that. Sometimes (former Wales captains) Alun Wyn Jones or Sam Warburton would ask me a couple of things. Personally, I don’t think a referee in camp needs to be a full-time role but South Africa and France are doing it and now so are Wales.’
One of the biggest things England learned from the summer was that their discipline was at its worst when the opposition had possession. More than 60 per cent of their penalties were conceded when they did not have the ball.
Subsequently, there has been more focus on getting the ball back quickly. The selection of turnover specialist Ben Curry at flanker has been central to their thought process. Limiting the opposition ruck count is a key target and Curry’s jackals killed Australian and Japanese attacks.
‘The biggest change is probably the defensive sets being a bit shorter,’ said England defence coach Richard Wigglesworth. ‘Inevitably, with the way the game’s refereed, the longer those sets go on, the more likely they’re going to pick something up.
‘With good players, you give them a few things to go after and they do it. Every defensive team probably wants the ball back. There are not too many teams that just want to contain. We certainly don’t want to be that defensive team. We want to put a team under pressure without the ball.’
England’s defensive system has evolved under Wigglesworth. They now apply more pressure around the ruck, with the likes of Ellis Genge and Maro Itoje flying up to disrupt the pass. Previously, the emphasis was on line speed being generated by the outside backs.
Nigel Owens, who became the first man to referee 100 Tests before retiring in 2020, is a fan of England bringing in a referee to consult
Maro Itoje (left) and Sam Underhill (centre) were both shown yellow cards in Rome in the Six Nations, costing England dear as they slipped to a first-ever defeat by Italy
Ben Curry (centre) has been crucial to England’s improved discipline as a fierce jackler
‘Change is not always as quick as you like,’ added Wigglesworth. ‘If the opposition have 100 rucks in their own half, you’d be pretty happy. If they have 100 rucks in your 22, you’re not going to be on the right end of it.
‘If they have multiple possessions over seven or eight-plus phases, you know they’ve gone back-to-back sets and they’re putting you under pressure. It’s different if it’s spread out between penalties and turnovers and our possessions.
‘It’s a different challenge against the All Blacks this week. We could talk about getting the ball back and the All Blacks could end up with 120 or 130 rucks.’
After four straight victories, the pressure has eased on Borthwick’s England. For now, they have shaken off their status as the world’s least-disciplined team.
Bigger Tests lie ahead, however, and Borthwick’s old mentor Eddie Jones, now Japan head coach, fired a sharp message: ‘When you’re on the front foot, you shouldn’t have discipline issues. Your discipline gets tested when you’re under the pump.’
