Pat Cummins’ captaincy on the brink? Australian cricket legend predicts Test skipper will be forced to stand down over explosive Sandpapergate revelations

Aussie cricket legend Mitchell Johnson has said he cannot see Pat Cummins’ captaincy surviving the sandpapergate saga, believing the pressure will eventually become too much on his former teammate.
Cummins’ status as skipper remains under intense focus, with Cameron Bancroft’s explosive statement on Wednesday dramatically raising the stakes.
Former opener David Warner, one of the three players banned by Cricket Australia over sandpapergate back in 2018, remained tight-lipped when asked repeated questions about Cummins and the captaincy.
But he did back Bancroft for coming out with his version of what transpired at Newlands in 2018 and since that explosive moment in the second Test against South Africa.
‘I think it’s a relief for Cameron to get it off his chest,’ Warner said.
Pressed on whether he agreed with everything Bancroft had said, Warner added: ‘I feel for him and it’s about Cameron telling the truth.’
David Warner refused to answer questions about Pat Cummins’ captaincy at Sydney Airport
The former Test opener was one of three players banned over the sandpaper scandal in 2018
The current Test captain was the youngest member of Australia’s bowling attack at the time of the 2018 Cape Town Test, a 24-year-old who was only seven months older than Bancroft.
But last Friday’s 68-minute press conference put Cummins front and centre, where he denied any knowledge of the 2018 ball-tampering plot prior to Bancroft being caught.
In his 4,512-word statement on Wednesday night, Bancroft insisted the entire team knew about the use of sandpaper and it was discussed at a meeting in front of the entire group.
Cummins’ camp has since remained adamant his position has not changed, and that the 34-year-old has already answered to all of the allegations raised by Bancroft.
Those close to Cummins and the rest of the bowling attack point out the group’s position has remained consistent since the moment Bancroft was spotted with sandpaper.
Regardless, the spotlight remains on the quick less than three weeks out from the first Test against New Zealand in Perth.
Mitchell Johnson played in Pat Cummins’ Test debut in 2011 and now says he cannot see his former teammate’s captaincy surviving the fallout
Pat Cummins denied during a 68-minute press conference that he knew about the ball-tampering plot before Cameron Bancroft was caught
Steve Smith, second from right, missed NSW training on Thursday but is expected to face Queensland in the Sheffield Shield before the first Test against New Zealand
‘The pressure on Cummins is now immense,’ Johnson wrote in his column for The West Australian.
‘I think he will still try to stand by what he has said and his statement with all of the bowlers back in 2021.
‘But I think the public pressure for Cummins to stand down as Test captain now will be too much.
‘I just can’t see how his captaincy and personal brand survives this.’
Johnson played in Cummins’ Test debut in South Africa 2011, and they were also teammates during Australia’s 2015 ODI World Cup success.
But the left-armer has previously been critical of the current Test captain, including during Justin Langer’s exit as coach in 2022 when he claimed the current side had ‘lost’ him.
In his latest column, Johnson said he believed Bancroft’s version of events given its detail, and feared the scandal was now impacting Australia’s next generation of players as it dragged on.
‘The act of using sandpaper was wrong,’ he wrote.
Cameron Bancroft claimed in a 4,512-word statement that the use of sandpaper was discussed in front of the entire Australian team
Former Australia captain Michael Clarke says fans deserve to know what happened and fears the scandal will drag on unless Cricket Australia establishes what occurred
‘But what followed was the truth not being told, the brotherhood not being a brotherhood, blokes thrown under the bus and the he-said, she-said that still won’t stop.
‘That has made it bigger than it ever should have been.’
Cummins trained with NSW on Thursday after being met with a throng of reporters outside of his house on the way to the SCG.
Beyond Johnson’s column, there are private fears within some quarters the current situation could prompt Cummins or other players from the 2018 side to walk away.
Steve Smith did not train on Thursday, but is still expected to play in the Sheffield Shield against Queensland come Sunday, in his only match before the first Test.
Johnson’s comments came as his former Test captain Michael Clarke also demanded the truth come out, rubbishing the belief there can be more than one valid version of events.
Hours before Bancroft’s column, Cricket Australia announced a forum where those in and around the Australian team that toured South Africa in 2018 can give their versions of events.
In announcing the move, chief executive Todd Greenberg said CA were not chasing ‘the perfect truth’, arguing there would be contradicting statements.
‘There is the truth. I call bull****. I don’t think there’s two sides to the story,’ Clarke said on his Beyond 23 podcast on Thursday.
‘If it’s not done properly it will keep going. I’m not picking a side right now, I’m saying there is no double truth or mixed truth there.
‘We aren’t sitting here because of the crime. We’re past the crime. It’s the behaviour post the crime – the lying.
‘I want to know the truth. The fans want to know the truth.’
