The cheaters’ playbook decoded: So many wives like me go mad looking for evidence, says ROSIE GREEN. But the real signs are so unexpected. If you spot them, it’s time to run

Updated:
The ending of a long marriage is sad. The ending of a long marriage where infidelity is involved is a s*** show. The betrayal, gaslighting, shame, guilt and mental torment that are by-products of an affair create a viper’s nest of toxic emotions. The intensity of which makes it impossible to navigate a separation amicably.
The very public breakdown of Ola and James Jordan’s 22-year marriage has unravelled under the shadow of his alleged affair. James is now with dancer Polina Mayer. He moved out of the family home this summer.
Ola says Polina’s ex-husband called her and told her they’d been having an affair whilst James was still married to her. James says ‘there was no affair’ and he has ‘grown closer’ to dancer Polina since his separation with Ola.
The truth is we don’t know what happened, or is happening, in their marriage.
What I do know is that Ola is in pain. Mentally tormented. In her words ‘broken’ and ‘lost.’
I know how that feels because I’ve been there.
I was married for 16 years when my husband announced he wanted out. Like Ola, it was not what I wanted. She said it ‘was not my decision’ and it was a ‘shock’. Same, same.
Like her I suspected another woman was involved. I hunted for evidence. Went half crazed trying to find proof. I was desperate for certainty in a time of so little.
Ola and her now ex-husband James Jordan in 2024. The very public breakdown of their 22-year marriage has unravelled under the shadow of his alleged affair
I wrote a book (How To Heal A Broken Heart) about my split and now have gathered a supportive community of people who’ve experienced traumatic break-ups.
Triggered by Ola’s story they’ve messaged me in their hundreds.
What became clear is that cheaters often show remarkably similar behaviours. Unwittingly adhering to the adultery playbook.
It goes like this. Have an affair, become cold, angry and vengeful towards your partner because a) they are an obstacle in the way of your new love and b) their presence makes you feel ashamed. If confronted about your affair vociferously deny it. Then slam down any probing questions with such violent force you won’t be asked again. This will make your partner feel like they are going mad, but at least it means they will question themselves more and you less.
Cheaters are also very certain they want out of a marriage. Most people when leaving a long-term marriage, will waver a few times and maybe try therapy, but if there is someone else in the wings they won’t want to try. And certainly, won’t want a counsellor probing as to their reasons for exiting.
They don’t want to admit an affair because that would make them a bad person and mean they have to face up to their guilt, so instead they separate from their current partner then leave a respectable amount of time before they announce they are together with their new love.
Their ex is told they are being left because of their terrible flaws (nagging/disorganised/uptight/extravagant etc). They are left mentally destabilised from being lied to by the person they trusted the most. And often end up dealing with devastated, distraught children.
(N.B. Another cheater cliché my community flag is the man who gets angry with his offspring for not being happy for him and his new partner. Then gets frustrated at their refusal to play nice at family occasions.)
I recognise it all. The piece of advice I have for those in the eye of the storm. Stop the hunting for proof. Because even if you find it, there’s a good chance your ex will deny it anyway. Instead use that energy to focus on yourself and rebuilding your life. And know there is good stuff on the other side of the pain.
Oh and Ola, whatever is happening in your life, I’m sending you all the love. You will survive. And then thrive. I know it.
