America’s ugliest divorce ended in assisted suicide: Horrifying footage from inside marital home and explosive allegations that sparked all-out war… as daughters speak out for the first time

It was a startling Facebook post that would shock anyone mid-scroll: A New York woman bid farewell to friends, loved ones and supporters – and while airing every dirty detail of her divorce drama, she announced that she would be ending her own life.
‘In the last four years of my life I have woken up every day to a nightmare like no other,’ Catherine Kassenoff penned in her final message on May 27, 2023, claiming that she could ‘no longer endure’ the alleged abuse of Allan Kassenoff, her husband of 16 years. It came as a shock to everyone despite Catherine’s tough life circumstances. ‘Don’t let my death be in vain,’ she added.
The post laid bare a broken relationship between two high-profile New York attorneys, which rotted into an unresolved divorce and ultimately a family lost. Before the legal battle, Catherine held a position in Governor Kathy Hochul’s office and in the aftermath of her death, Allan, a patent litigator for clients like Pfizer and Samsung, left his partnership at Greenberg Traurig.
The divorce proceedings triggered a nasty custody battle, during which Catherine claimed she was at the mercy of a corrupt legal system allegedly levied by Allan to bar her from their children, as every sordid detail went viral on TikTok.
That same day as her final post, which shocked her friends and those who supported her, Catherine emailed hundreds of individuals – from friends to members of the legal system – a final ‘swan song’ filled with court documents, therapy records and videos of her estranged husband she claimed ‘showed exactly how abusive Allan Kassenoff is.’ Her email began, ‘This is a story that ends with my own assisted death in Switzerland.’
Three years after her death, the battle wages on; this time moving from the courts to TV screens. He Said, She Said: Till Death Do Us Part, streaming on November 17 on Paramount+, digs deeper into the tragedy through interviews with Allan and their three daughters – aged just 16, 15 and 13 – who allege Catherine was the true culprit of abuse which has caused the family an unimaginable amount of grief and distress and even resulted in death threats.
But a nanny for the family, Katherine Klein, who allegedly was the last person to speak to Catherine, told the Daily Mail that accusations of abuse by the mother-of-three following her suicide were not ‘fair.’
On May 27, 2023, the day Catherine ended her life, Klein said she received the email and immediately called her. Klein begged her not to do it, but Catherine had informed her that it was too late. Not only had her decision been made, but it was also already underway.
Catherine Kassenoff penned in her final message on May 27, 2023, claiming that she could ‘no longer endure’ the alleged abuse of Allan Kassenoff, her husband of 16 years
‘In the last four years of my life, I have woken up every day to a nightmare like no other. I can no longer endure the abuse and terror of Allan Kassenoff… I have also endured the emotional devastation of being without my children for so long…’
‘She’s no longer here,’ Klein said with remorse for her friend, not wanting to discuss their final phone call.
But Klein claims she witnessed Catherine and Allan’s verbal spats firsthand. ‘It’s not fair how he wore her down and, like, beat her to dust in a sense, like he really, he pulverized her verbally and mentally,’ she said. ‘It really wears a person down.’
Allan and Catherine first met in 2005 in New York City when they were 33 and 37 respectively and working together at his law firm. They bonded over their shared profession, and he loved that she was ‘no-nonsense.’
‘It was an attractive quality,’ he said in the docuseries.
Early on, religion became a contentious point for the pair, who were raised in different faiths. While Allan was raised in an Orthodox Jewish family in New York, Catherine’s family based in West Virginia were Egyptian Coptic Christians. She converted to Judaism before the marriage, but choosing their wedding venue was difficult due to faith-based concerns that put their families at odds.
Ultimately, they eloped in Puerto Rico only one year after they began dating. It’s unknown if their families attended the ceremony.
Catherine had dreams of becoming a mother, leading them to put down roots and jumpstart their family plans soon after marrying.
Less than two years into their marriage, Catherine was diagnosed with rare, aggressive breast cancer, and the illness and the treatment she underwent took a toll on their relationship. She told a therapist that Allan ‘showed that he was not good at handling stress,’ according to details she shared in her final post.
While Catherine managed her illness, the couple adopted a daughter, Alexandra ‘Ally’ Kassenoff. She wanted more kids and sought out in vitro fertilization, which Allan said in the documentary that she was ready to do ‘with or without me.’ Eventually, they conceived two more girls via IVF, Charlotte ‘Charley’ Kassenoff and Josephina ‘Jojo’ Kassenoff, despite growing tears in their relationship.
The couple moved to a big house in Westchester County, New York, decorating their home with family pictures. To the outside world, they appeared to be a well-managed, happy family with two career-oriented, well-to-do parents. Inside the walls of their wood-paneled home was anything but well-managed.
The couple’s relationship began to crumble as they increasingly became ensnared in arguments over parenting responsibilities and personal conflicts. Allan previously described the relationship as a ‘rollercoaster’ with disastrous lows due to the constant bickering mixed with strong highs but was reluctant to describe those bright points.
Allan said in the doc that he loved being a father, but was often busy working late, frequently leaving Catherine with sole responsibility for the children.
Allan and Catherine first met in 2005 in New York City when they were 33 and 37 respectively
Less than two years into their marriage, Catherine was diagnosed with rare, aggressive breast cancer
Catherine’s friend, Cynthia Monaco, told producers for the documentary that she didn’t witness ‘lovey-dovey’ affection between the pair, and she described Allan as ‘immature.’
‘When everyone urged her to leave an explosive marriage, she said her children had a beautiful life and she did not want to disrupt it,’ she wrote on a GoFundMe after Catherine’s death.
Further strain was placed on the family in 2017 when Catherine was diagnosed with breast cancer again, though much about her second battle is unknown.
When a split became inevitable, and divorce proceedings commenced in May 2019, each parent grew determined to get the other’s actions and fighting words on camera – footage which would later be turned over to both family court and the court of public opinion.
In court documents and divorce proceedings, Catherine alleged Allan abused her verbally and physically and claimed his side of the story falsely painted her as the perpetrator of abuse against their children. Allan denied the allegations.
A custody evaluation claimed Catherine suffered from ‘an unspecified personality disorder, predominately histrionic and narcissistic traits’ and accused Catherine of ‘gaslighting’ and alienating and coaching the children against their father.
However, Catherine’s own psychiatrist, who told the court during a temporary custody trial in 2020 she worked with Catherine for over a year due to alleged ‘spousal and emotional physical abuse, divorce, separation from the children,’ claimed during the trial she ‘does not exhibit any features or problems relating to mental health issues.’
While the evaluation conceded Allan was ’emotionally unsophisticated’ and contributed to a ‘noxious atmosphere,’ the evaluation claimed his bursts of outrage were spurred by Catherine’s presence and actions. The evaluation observed Allan would flee from Catherine rather than stand up to her. The court did not find evidence of abuse by Allan. No criminal charges were filed against Allan.
The evaluation resulted in the removal of the daughters, who were approximately ten, eight and six years old, from Catherine’s care, citing the court appointed custody evaluator’s assessment that Catherine’s mental health issues prevented her from caring for the children.
She connected with her daughters via video calls, in part due to the Covid-19 pandemic lockdowns, and was required to pay a third-party supervisor for all visits.
During this time, against advice from her attorney and the court, Catherine spoke openly about the case, writing disparaging remarks about Allan and shared videos on social media of her family in embittered moments, like one showing Ally standing up for her sisters following one of Allan’s vocal outbursts, seen in the docuseries.
Allan was a patent litigator for clients like Pfizer and Samsung as partner at Greenberg Traurig
The couple’s relationship began to crumble as they increasingly became ensnared in arguments over parenting responsibilities and personal conflicts
Catherine and Allan both sank significant money into the custody battle.
‘The financial situation was dire. Catherine grew thin from stress,’ Monaco wrote in the GoFundMe.
According to a since-deleted Ms Magazine interview viewed by the Daily Mail, the financial toll of her custody battle caused her to liquidate her retirement savings, since the supervised visits and legal bills reportedly ran her over $70,000.
Allan claimed in an email previously published by the Daily Mail to Catherine he would ‘never stop’ keeping her from the kids and alleged he sank at least $3 million into the process.
‘Even if this Court awards you my last dollar, I will never stop protecting them,’ Allan wrote in the email. ‘Until the day I die.’
Just two months before her suicide note, Catherine filed a lawsuit against Allan and his attorneys, alleging false imprisonment, but the legal recourse and their divorce were never formally resolved.
The process in Switzerland takes between six weeks and six months and requires a statement about the patient’s suffering. It’s unclear how long she planned her death as those in her circle were shocked by her decision. She did not inform friends, family or her medical team before seeking assisted suicide.
A medical report from former psychiatrist Colin Brewer was dated April 9, 2023, and confirmed Catherine was in ‘sound enough mind’ to terminate her life. He confirmed to The Free Press he spoke with Catherine multiple times across several months.
Catherine’s demise was an ‘existential assisted suicide,’ Brewer concluded in the report.
Her legal battle was coupled with a third breast cancer diagnosis, which she described as ‘terminal’ in her final post; a detail Allan later disputed. She cited the reportedly terminal illness as a contributing factor to her decision, but the psychiatrist stressed the emotional weight of the custody battle was the primary concern.
Catherine was more ‘concerned that she had been treated abominably by her husband,’ causing ‘understandable misery’ and she was less worried about terminal illness, according to Brewer.
She ended her life officially at the Pegasos Swiss Association after her public post and a few phone calls from concerned loved ones. However, confirmation of her death took weeks to arrive through international government records. Catherine’s suicide effectively ended the marriage.
Catherine did not inform friends, family or her medical team before seeking assisted suicide, which completely blindsided everyone on May 27, 2023
Catherine and Allan both sank significant money into the custody battle
Allan claimed in the docuseries that Catherine was ‘a very difficult person to get along with.’ He compared Catherine’s death to that of a suicide bomber, claiming it was as much of an effort to bring him down as it was for her to escape the emotional burden.
For Ally, the eldest daughter who is now 16, her sisters’ arrivals changed her relationship with her mother early on, she claimed in the docuseries.
‘My mom told me, when I was like four or five, that I was adopted. I was adopted because she couldn’t have kids, and, as soon as she was able to have her own kids, I was not her kid at that point,’ Ally told filmmakers.
Multiple family nannies, but not all, alleged to producers Catherine was abusive toward the children, especially Ally. Klein claimed Allan abused Catherine and instilled fear into the children. Allan has consistently denied allegations of abuse.
One nanny, Kim Hull, who worked for the couple in 2009, alleged Catherine punished Ally by ‘dripping water’ on her all day to prevent her from sleeping. Hull claimed she found marks resembling fingernail scratches on Ally’s back when she was just a baby.
Mylene Gry, who was employed as a nanny from 2015 to 2016, claimed Catherine shouted at Ally, who was approximately younger than ten, telling her: ‘You have no friends… you’re never going to get married.’
Gry, who feared Catherine, compared Ally to Cinderella, claiming she was forced to be ‘like a maid’ to her siblings.
Regardless, their efforts generated countless clips for the docuseries, which displayed each parent’s personal insults and the tears of their watchful children.
In one video featured in the series, Allan insisted he ‘hated’ his wife, regretting his time with her. In another, he branded her a ‘fat loser’ and allegedly threatened to release a video of her in just underwear. He stormed away during angry outbursts, at times refusing to care for the children. He has commented about his state of anger at the time but denies any abuse.
Other footage shot by Allan showed Catherine scolding all three girls when they didn’t live up to the high academic and extracurricular standards she set for them early. In one video, Catherine ridiculed Ally for stealing a chocolate bar and lying as Allan begged his wife to treat their daughter ‘civilly.’ She reportedly encouraged them to disparage their father on film.
Child Protective Services was tipped off about the family fighting, according to the docuseries.
Ally, who was 13 when her mother died, told filmmakers: ‘I told my school that my dad kicked me. I don’t remember why and my mom thought it was like the best thing ever that I said that.’
Ally told producers she cannot recall physical abuse from her father, who has denied allegations of abuse.
In the docuseries, Allan claimed that the judge ultimately sided with him due to video evidence he submitted.
In one video featured in the series, Allan insisted he ‘hated’ his wife, regretting his time with her
‘Even if this Court awards you my last dollar, I will never stop protecting them,’ Allan wrote in an email
While Allan claimed the children did not pick a side early in the separation, videos in the docuseries showed the girls disclosing concerns about their safety to Catherine. She encouraged them to go to police if necessary. The docuseries featured videos of the girls speaking in French – Catherine and the children spoke French, though it’s unclear if Allan was fluent – and keeping their voices low, making efforts to avoid their father’s nearby ear.
When Ally made a trip to the nearby police station, Catherine reportedly rode nearby in her car to follow her there, cautious of limitations imposed by the court about visitation.
Allan, though, supposedly became concerned Catherine was instructing the girls to defect from his care and accused Catherine of posing as their nine-year-old daughter Charley and sending emails from her account which detailed extreme distress and suicidal ideation under Allan’s care.
Catherine denied she was behind the emails – but the court sided with Allan and mandated all visits to include a third-party supervisor.
Charley, who was 12 when her mother died, said: ‘I never thought for myself. [My mom], like, put her voice through my mouth.’
The children’s therapist claimed to Catherine, per audio included in the docuseries, she asked Charley about the video. Charley did not deny sending the email but claimed she did not have a plan for suicide and simply missed her mother.
Videos showed Catherine emotional on video calls, crying in the presence of a third-party supervisor, as her daughters grew cold and distant.
While Catherine’s actions and behavior were sometimes indisputably heated or emotionally charged, Natalie Blundell, who she met through a support group for mothers navigating family courts, said she could understand what Catherine might have been going through.
‘What I observed in Catherine and have observed in other women is that when you’re pushed so far, you’re so desperate to end this madness, to see your kids again, you would try anything,’ Blundell said in the docuseries. ‘I think, as any mother would, you will do what you need to do.’
Andrew Firsh, Catherine’s attorney and colleague, said the family court process for the Kassenoffs was brutal.
‘When I came into the case, I had never worked in matrimonial court,’ he told producers, adding: ‘This was a war, and in my first conversation with Allan’s lawyer, he said, “Matrimonial practices is a cesspool. I do what I have to.”‘
One attorney for Catherine, Evan Wiederkehr, claimed she felt ‘shackled’ by the judge’s decisions.
‘If you weren’t insane before, it’s enough to make you insane,’ he told producers of Catherine’s case.
Before Catherine’s death, she was allowed extended visits with her children. However, the girls left with even more resentment, according to the docuseries, and their relationship never repaired.
Charley and Jojo began skipping visits, leaving only Ally, who said she was still ‘vying for her mother’s affection.’ When Ally sought closure over the alleged abuse inflicted by Catherine, she claimed her mother fell quiet.
‘There was about two minutes of silence,’ Ally recalled. ‘And then she said, “I’m sorry.” And that was it. She didn’t feel any emotion about it at all.’
Wayne Baker, Catherine’s friend and estate executor, recalled in the docuseries Catherine’s love for her kids and saying: ‘The court said I cannot live with my children, but I cannot live without them.’
Meanwhile, Catherine’s friends maintain her character was inconsistent with abuse.
Monaco told the Daily Mail that Catherine was a ‘wonderful person,’ adding ‘I owe a tremendous amount [to her], including my decision to have two children.’
Monaco shared that both she and Catherine had a similar cancer diagnosis, and Catherine’s decision to pursue motherhood in the face of medical adversity was inspiring to her.
Catherine died with a final request to her close friends, as she did in her final social media post, to make sure her children knew her version of the ‘truth.’
‘The reason Catherine’s friends agreed to participate in this documentary was because it was going to go forward without her, and one way or the other, and we thought we should try and give her a voice,’ Monaco said.
Allan claimed in the docuseries that Catherine was ‘a very difficult person to get along with’
Before her assisted suicide, Catherine spoke openly about the case, writing disparaging remarks about Allan and shared videos on social media
The Daily Mail has reached out to Allan Kassenoff for comment.
One friend, who spoke to the Daily Mail under the condition of anonymity, told the Daily Mail they plan to honor Catherine’s wishes.
They said: ‘I feel that when her girls are of age, and they’re independent from [Allan], I will gladly tell them and share with them all of my correspondence with their mother, and I will gladly tell them everything I know and remember about their beautiful mother.’
‘It makes me sick to think that they’re going to smear her,’ the friend, who had not yet viewed the docuseries, said, insisting Catherine previously attempted to tell her story through an ‘exposé on the broken family court system,’ in a similar format to the docuseries, but ‘no one was interested.’
While He Said, She Said left Allan’s voice echoing in the air, Baker told producers there’s still a final message from her – a video for her daughters’ eyes only which they have not yet seen.
He told filmmakers: ‘She just tries to explain to the girls what lessons she learned during her life, the importance of being able to reach your goals, not letting things that happened previously dictate what your life is going to be. She just wanted them to know her decision to end her life wasn’t predicated to anything they did.’
The Daily Mail has contacted Baker for comment.
If you or someone you love is experiencing suicidal thoughts or actions, call the National Suicide Hotline at 988.
