Are sweet potato fries healthier than classic french fries? Nutritionist reveals which is best for you… and whether to keep the skin on

Sweet potato fries have become something of a health-food darling – popping up on restaurant menus and supermarket shelves as the supposedly virtuous alternative to the basic french fry.
With their vibrant orange colour, naturally sweet flavour and reputation for being packed with nutrients, it’s easy to see why so many of us have been persuaded that swapping potatoes for sweet potatoes is a smarter choice.
But do they really deserve their healthy halo? Or are we simply kidding ourselves when we order a portion alongside our burger, convinced we’ve made the better choice?
The truth, it turns out, is a little more complicated.
While sweet potatoes offer some nutritional advantages over regular potatoes, the way they’re prepared – and what they’re cooked in – can make a significant difference, say experts.
A deep-fried portion may have rather more in common with traditional chips than you think.
So, are sweet potato fries genuinely the healthier option, or is the good old french fry unfairly getting a bad rap? We asked nutritionists to weigh in on the great chip debate.
Are sweet potato fries actually a healthier side option?
What’s in sweet potato fries?
Originally from the tropical regions of Central and South America, sweet potatoes are actually not potatoes at all, but rather root vegetables.
Their impressive vitamin concentration and lower calorie content has seen them adopted into diets worldwide – often billed as a healthier alternative to traditional russet potato chips.
Sweet potatoes are packed with beta-carotene, a powerful antioxidant that the body converts into vitamin A, which plays an important role in maintaining healthy eyesight, supporting the immune system and keeping skin in good condition.
In fact, just one medium sweet potato can provide more than the recommended daily amount of vitamin A, research shows.
They’re also a good source of fibre, which helps support digestion, keeps bowel movements regular and can help you feel fuller for longer.
Finally, sweet potatoes contain an impressive amount of vitamin C, which helps with collagen production and immune function, as well as potassium, an important mineral for regulating blood pressure and supporting normal muscle function.
They also provide vitamin B6 and manganese, both of which play a role in the body’s metabolism.
Like french fries, sweet potato fries are made from thin strips of potatoes that are cooked to a deep, golden brown colour, and are commonly paired with tomato ketchup and mayonnaise.
Are they a healthier alternative to traditional chips?
Despite the many nutritional benefits of the sweet potato, sweet potato fries are less decisively a healthy choice, say experts.
According to Rob Hobson, registered nutritionist and the author of Unprocess Your Life, the popular snack have actually developed ‘a health halo’.
‘Both sweet potato and regular fries are sources of carbohydrate, and once they’re deep-fried, they can contain similar amounts of calories and fat,’ he explains.
‘As a result, a lot depends on how they’re prepared, how much oil they absorb and the size of the portion.
‘The main nutritional advantage of sweet potatoes is their beta-carotene content, which gives them their orange colour.
‘The body converts this into vitamin A, which is important for healthy vision, immune function and skin. They also provide fibre and potassium, although regular potatoes contain these nutrients too, alongside vitamin B6 and some vitamin C.’
He said there was a ‘common misconception’ that sweet potato fries were better for blood sugar because of their lower glycaemic index, meaning the rate at which they raise blood sugar levels.
The way in which potatoes are cooked is key to their nutritional value, nutritionist Rob Hobson said
In fact, Mr Hobson says, it’s not quite that straightforward.
‘The glycaemic index of both potatoes varies depending on how they’re cooked, and both provide carbohydrates that are broken down into glucose,’ he says.
Portion size and what you eat alongside them also influence the blood sugar response.
Pairing sweet potato fries with a source of protein, such as chicken, fish or eggs, and healthy fats can help slow digestion and moderate the rise in blood glucose, says Mr Hobson.
The assumption that sweet potato is far higher in fibre – the vital nutrient that can reduce bowel cancer risk and lower cholesterol – isn’t quite right either.
In fact, a portion has only a small amount more fibre than french fries (0.2g), and skin-on fries have marginally more.
Mr Hobson also cautioned that sweet potato fries were not automatically lower in calories.
‘If you compare two similar portions cooked in the same way, the calorie difference may be relatively small,’ says Mr Hobson.
‘Some commercially-prepared sweet potato fries also have added coatings to help them crisp up, so it’s worth checking the ingredients and nutritional information rather than assuming they’re the healthier option.
‘The cooking method probably makes the biggest difference. Baking or air-frying either type with a little oil will generally produce a lower-fat option than deep-frying.
‘I would say to choose whichever one you enjoy most. Both can fit into a healthy diet, and the portion size, cooking method and what you eat alongside them are probably more important than which potato you choose.’
So, do sweet potato fries match up to the alternatives?
We collated nutritional information on different fry options:
| Type | Calories | Fat | Carbohydrates | Fibre | Salt |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| French fries | 290 | 14.2g | 39.7g | 3.8g | 0.5g |
| Skin-on fries | 155 | 3g | 34.7g | 4.2g | 0.2g |
| Chip-shop chips | 214 | 8.4g | 33.2g | 3.2g | 0.1g |
| Triple-cooked chips | 180 | 6.5g | 26.3g | 3.3g | 0.4g |
| Oven chips | 190 | 5g | 35.3g | 3.5g | 0.1g |
| Sweet potato fries | 153 | 0.8g | 36.6g | 4g | 0.2g |
Sweet potato fries are the best option calorically, although Hobson adds that these figures are based on an average product – and doesn’t account for the types with extra coatings added.
Skin-on fries – which are made from unpeeled potatoes – are similarly lower in calories, due to the increased surface area of the chip that soaks up less oil than a skinny version.
French fries and chip shop chips are among the fattiest and most calorific, while french fries also have the highest salt count.
Mr Hobson cautioned: ‘It’s worth remembering that chips are ultimately a side dish rather than a major source of nutrition, so the overall quality of the meal – the foods you have alongside the chips – is what matters most.’
