Crippling pain SO often mistaken for arthritis – even by doctors. It’s a common condition fixed by one simple jab. Charlotte feared she’d need a hip replacement. Now she says: I feel amazing

For ten years Charlotte Lister was convinced she was soon going to need a hip replacement. At times, even a brief walk to the shops left the former Miss Great Britain finalist wincing in pain, and often she was unable to sleep.
‘Driving hurt, walking hurt, cold made the hip pain flare up – I began to feel like an 80-year-old in a 40-year-old’s body,’ says Charlotte, now 39.
Despite seeing her GP time and again she was told the pain wasn’t anything to worry about.
‘But sometimes I was in tears – it was so bad I was convinced I had arthritis. I had to sleep with a pregnancy pillow between my knees to relieve the pressure on my hips.
‘I wondered if I needed to go private and get a hip replacement.’
But earlier this year by chance she saw a new GP – and was told she had an entirely different, and often treatable condition, bursitis.
This is the name given to inflammation of the bursa – these are small fluid-filled sacs that act as a cushion between bones and surrounding tissues.
‘We have more than 150 bursae around the body,’ explains Caesar Wek, an NHS consultant orthopaedic hip and knee surgeon in Dorset. ‘They sit wherever tendons, muscles or skin glide over bone.’
Charlotte Lister competed as a Miss Great Britain finalist, reaching the Top 15
However, repeated friction or pressure, a knock or a fall, or less commonly an inflammatory condition such as gout or rheumatoid arthritis, can cause a bursa to become inflamed – the most commonly affected are bursae in the shoulder, the point of the elbow, the front of the knee, the back of the heel and, as in Charlotte’s case, the outside of the hip.
This form, known as trochanteric bursitis, affects the bursae sitting over the greater trochanter, the bony lump you can feel at the top of the thigh bone.
It ‘usually causes an ache or a burning pain on the outside of the hip’, says Mr Wek – ‘and occasionally, the discomfort travels down the outside of the thigh towards the knee.’
‘Patients typically complain of not being able to lie on that side at night as this will put pressure on the irritated bursa and tendon.
‘It also hurts getting up out of a chair, using stairs, after standing or walking for a while – and if you press on the point of the hip it’s very sore.’
This type of bursitis is one of a collection of conditions affecting the area around the hip, thigh or buttock known under the umbrella term greater trochanteric pain syndrome (GTPS).
As well as bursitis, this includes gluteal tendinopathy, or wear and tear – sometimes partial tearing – of the tendons that attach to the deep buttock muscles and hold your pelvis level when you stand on one leg. ‘Without them you’d lurch sideways with every step,’ Mr Wek explains. That’s why people affected tend to move in this way.
‘It’s mostly people aged 40 to 60, typically in their fifties who are affected, although you do see it in younger, sporty people,’ he adds.
The problem occurs when the tendon becomes frayed rather than inflamed and symptoms he says, are similar to bursitis except there is weakness as well as pain at the side of the hip.
Hormones – in particular falling oestrogen levels – are also implicated in GTPS as they are thought to play a role in maintaining the structure and function of tendons.
GTPS is a common problem, says Professor Sion Glyn-Jones, a consultant orthopaedic surgeon at Nuffield Orthopaedic Centre (NHS) and Nuffield Health Oxford, with studies showing that around a fifth of the population experience symptoms of it.
And because of the overlap with the symptoms of osteoarthritis of the hip and GTPS, the ‘two get mixed up all the time by patients and doctors’, Mr Wek says.
‘Both give you hip pain, a limp and trouble on stairs, and both hit the same age group – coming on between the 40s and 60s.’
But there are reliable ways to tell them apart, he adds.
Hip osteoarthritis affects the ball-and-socket joint itself, causing the bones to rub against each other leading to pain and difficulty moving the joint.
M Caesar Wek says when it comes to bursitis specifically it can affect ‘younger, sporty people, runners in particular
Charlotte’s problems in her hip began after running a half marathon in 2016
‘The pain is classically in the groin, sometimes the buttock or front of the thigh, and it can be felt in the knee,’ explains Mr Wek. ‘The hip gets stiff, so people struggle with socks and shoes, cutting their toenails and getting in and out of the car. Rotating the hip can be restricted and painful.’
Meanwhile GTPS is a problem outside the joint – the pain is felt on the side, but the joint itself still moves fine. These patients can usually still reach their feet.’
Mr Wek says when it comes to bursitis specifically it can affect ‘younger, sporty people, runners in particular. Women are more likely to suffer – roughly three or four women to one man. The wider female pelvis means the tendon wraps round the trochanter at a sharper angle and gets compressed more, and hormonal changes around the menopause affect tendon quality.’
Charlotte’s problems began after running a half marathon in 2016.
‘I thought it was just post-race aches and pains or perhaps I’d pulled a muscle in my hip,’ she says.
‘But as the days passed the pain was worse. It started in my hip and radiated down to my knee.’
Charlotte – who works in hotel management and lives in Nottinghamshire with partner Craig, 62, and her 15-year-old daughter – saw her GP who explained the marathon had probably caused an injury and recommended rest and heat or ice packs. ‘I did this for days, then weeks but the pain remained,’ she says.
Over the months Charlotte was back and forth to her GP who told her to take anti-inflammatories and continue with heat or ice.
‘But it just didn’t get better. I worried I’d done irreparable damage.’
Finally, this year when she saw a different GP he told her it sounded like bursitis ‘which I had never heard of,’ she says and she would need a steroid injection ‘there and then.’
‘It was very painful and made me cry out. The GP said that was all the confirmation we needed that it was indeed bursitis because it had gone into the painful “spot” [that characterises the condition].’
‘After the injection I felt amazing – my hip was pain-free, I could move easily and all the discomfort had gone. It felt like a miracle. I was also so relieved I didn’t have arthritis and wouldn’t need surgery.’
Charlotte was also given physiotherapy exercises to reduce inflammation and strengthen muscles.
A steroid injection into the bursa should ideally be done using ultrasound to guide it, says Mr Wek. ‘It gives good short-term relief in most people and is useful for breaking the pain cycle so they can actually do their physio’. (The effect of the injection tends to wear off at around three months, ‘and repeated steroid can weaken the tendon, so I’m spare with them’, he adds.)
Indeed, for long-term benefits ‘a well-structured education and exercise programme’ is key, Matt Harrison, spokesman for the Chartered Society of Physiotherapists, told the Daily Mail.
The aim of such programmes – usually lasting two to three months – is to strengthen the hip muscles to correct movement patterns and stabilise the pelvis. Mr Wek says that as well as physio, it’s important to take the pressure off the hip (not lying on that side, not sitting cross-legged, not standing with all your weight on one hip).
Another option is shockwave therapy – where sound waves are used to boost blood flow to trigger healing and reduce pain – ‘which has reasonable evidence for the chronic cases where physio alone hasn’t worked,’ says Mr Wek. ‘Surgery is for the small minority who are still struggling after six to twelve months of proper non-operative treatment – options include removing the bursa which can be done keyhole.’
Professor Glyn-Jones adds there is a newer treatment of platelet-rich plasma which involves taking the patient’s own blood, and removing the platelets, which contain growth factors which stimulate healing.
He says: ‘Early studies reported encouraging results. However, more recent research has been less convincing. PRP therefore remains an area of ongoing development rather than an established treatment.’
This treatment is only available privately.
After a few weeks the effect of Charlotte’s steroid injection wore off: ‘I was warned it would. My physio exercises help a little but nowhere near as much as the injection and now I am looking forward to having another one soon.’
