Four sick women, vulnerable and in pain who were not believed by their doctors. Here’s why it’s past time to start asking if Irish women are being gaslit by the medical profession…

They did what patients are told to do – they trusted their doctors. All four would later wonder if they should have trusted themselves.
Five days after giving birth, Pauline O’Shea believed the cardiologist who told her there was nothing wrong with her heart.
Sarah Lee believed the gynaecologist who told her she had nothing to be anxious about. Samantha Trevaskis left her first assessment thinking she was ‘crazy’.
Sharon Keegan spent decades thinking she was the problem.
Pauline was 38, with a newborn daughter and two sons, aged seven and nine, still getting used to the new arrival.
She was halfway down the stairs when she felt as though a cage was being torn open in her chest. She managed to reach a chair, where she sat almost motionless for half an hour. Each time she tried to speak, the pain returned.
‘I just had to be like a statue,’ she says. ‘Instinctively I knew movement was not my friend.’
She had no idea she was having a heart attack. Earlier that evening, her blood pressure monitor had shown alarming readings and she had developed a severe headache.
The out-of-hours service told her to see her GP in the morning. Now, with the pain in her chest, she asked her husband to ring the doctor again.
Paramedics did an ECG in her kitchen and found something they could not identify. ‘We feel you should go in,’ they said.
Pauline was 38, with a newborn daughter and two sons, aged seven and nine, still getting used to the new arrival
She reached the emergency department at around 9pm. It was midday the following day before a cardiologist came to see her.
He did not draw back the curtain. He put his head round it, glanced at the monitor and said, ‘Your heart is fine.’ Then he left.
‘That was my consult,’ Pauline says.
Outside, she could hear a nurse pleading with someone to examine her. ‘She’s here since last night. Will you please look at her?’
Pauline heard every word. ‘I was nearly seen as a time-waster,’ she recalls.
A further scan showed her heart function was low. That could be down to having just given birth, she was told, or to a virus.
She was discharged on Holy Thursday with no medication and an appointment for six weeks later.
She had been told her heart was fine and she believed it. She was going home to her baby and her two boys, with Easter just days away.
She would be there to help the boys settle in with their new sister, as she had wanted. The fright was over, she could just be a mother again.
On Easter Saturday the pain returned, just as it had before. Again she sat perfectly still and endured it. This time she did not call for help.
‘They’ve told me it’s a virus,’ she says. ‘I’ve just got to suck it up. There’s no point going back in.’ That night she was unable to make it upstairs to bed.
Almost a week later, her GP visited the house, listened to her erratic heartbeat and sent her straight back to hospital.
There, she was asked why she had not come in sooner. She had, she said. She had spent nearly 48 hours there.
Then she went into cardiac arrest. Twice she was resuscitated. She was rushed for an angiogram, a test she says had not been ordered first time round, and told to sign a form and say goodbye to everybody.
When she woke after emergency bypass surgery, she learned it had never been a virus.
She had suffered a spontaneous coronary artery dissection, or SCAD, a tear in the wall of an artery supplying the heart.
By the time she reached theatre, the artery was ‘in tatters’ and she had been surviving on the other one.
‘Luck kept me alive,’ she reveals.
The blood pressure readings, the headache and the tearing pain had all been real. She believes her age and slim build counted against her.
She did not look, she says, like someone having a heart attack, and she kept hearing: ‘You’re postpartum, right?’
For years afterwards her heart function remained at just 20 or 25 per cent. She no longer had the energy to be the mother she wanted to be. For weeks she could not hold her baby.
When she finally could, she worried that if she died, the child might bang her head on something. ‘If I’d been diagnosed on time, I’d certainly have had a better chance,’ she says.
‘My pipework was fixed, but the pump was deprived.’
Sarah Lee was 14 when her pain began, but it would be more than a decade before she discovered what was causing it. Over the years she learned to keep quiet about her symptoms.
A GP suggested contraception. The pill made her feel dreadful, while an Implanon rod kept the worst of it at bay for three years. When it was removed, ‘everything just ramped up tenfold’.
She fainted and spent days unable to get out of bed. Her family would say, ‘Oh, you poor thing!’ but add that some people simply had worse periods than others.
For years, whenever anyone asked how she was, she said she was grand.
A gynaecologist left Sarah distraught. He told her, she recalls, that she was ‘a young girl living in a good country’ with ‘nothing to be anxious about’.
He also suggested she should have brought her boyfriend to the appointment because he might ‘understand better’.
Sarah Lee was 14 when her pain began, but it would be more than a decade before she discovered what was causing it
In a letter to her GP, she says, the gynaecologist raised questions about her mental health and suggested he should operate ‘just to shut me up’.
Sarah rang her GP in bits and after years of being told it was just bad periods, her ‘amazing GP’ was the first person to suggest what might be wrong.
‘You never, ever have to go back to him again,’ the GP told her.
She would refer her elsewhere, Sarah says, and make a complaint to the medical board.
Two operations in Ireland followed. There were long periods when Sarah could not work, episodes of fainting and blood in her urine.
When she turned up at A&E, she was given morphine and told to contact her consultant. By then she had tried every treatment offered to her, including chemical menopause.
‘I knew something was wrong,’ she says.
Eventually Sarah found Dr Konstantinos Kyriakopoulos, known as Dr Dinos, in Athens.
Even as she prepared for a third operation, she wondered whether the surgeons would find anything at all.
‘I knew the pain didn’t relate,’ she says. ‘I knew there was something underlying.’
There was. Endometriosis had reached her bladder, her sigmoid colon and her ureters.
Within a week of the operation, her urinary symptoms had disappeared. She told her GP that her recovery was ‘not a fraction’ of the pain she had endured for years.
She has since stopped all her medication and is now pregnant. Her message to any woman in a GP’s waiting room is stark: ‘Don’t let someone tell you it’s in your head. Unfortunately, we have to be our own advocates a lot of the time.’
Samantha Trevaskis was 18 when she first went for an assessment. She was asked to keep a mood diary for two weeks, despite having a four-week cycle, then sent on her way. ‘I left that appointment thinking, I’m just crazy,’ she says. ‘Literally crazy.’
It would be another 15 years before she understood what was happening to her. Her symptoms began a week after her period ended, leaving her struggling three weeks out of every month.
She sometimes called in sick with stomach bugs she did not have, because she had no other way of explaining what she was going through. Only her mother seemed to see ‘the real me’.
Her best friend, who she had known since they were 14, once abandoned a date with a boyfriend she really liked and took a taxi across the city after Samantha rang her in tears.
Samantha Trevaskis was 18 when she first went for an assessment. ‘I left that appointment thinking, I’m just crazy,’ she says. ‘Literally crazy.’
When she arrived, Samantha was sitting there, happy as Larry, laughing and joking.
‘I literally just left this fella that I’m seeing, who I really like,’ Samantha remembers her friend saying, ‘and there’s nothing wrong with you.’ Her friend forgave her anyway. She always did.
The answer came almost by accident. Samantha began an injection that induces chemical menopause, as part of an agreement with a gynaecologist who had always believed her.
If the pain stopped, he would remove the ovary she was convinced was causing it.
Two weeks later, she turned to her mother. ‘Is this what life is supposed to be like?’ she asked. ‘Is this how everyone experiences life?’
At her three-month check-up, she told him what had changed. While studying for her master’s in psychological science, she had come across premenstrual dysphoric disorder, or PMDD.
Now 35, she has just submitted a PhD thesis on the condition. PMDD, she says, affects an estimated 3-8 per cent of women, and she calls it ‘PMS on steroids’.
It was included in the American Psychiatric Association’s diagnostic manual in 2013 and the World Health Organisation’s classification in 2019, but when Samantha was 18, it was in neither.
It’s a condition that still needs much work to recognise and treat.
For Sharon Keegan, it was an appointment with her ten-year-old son in a psychiatrist’s office that made her sit up and take notice.
A teacher had suggested an assessment after her son struggled to sit through dinner but Sharon recognised herself in the answers he was giving.
‘It was like a smack in the face,’ she says. Now 44, Sharon is a Walkinstown entrepreneur who founded the fitness-wear brand Peachylean and appeared on Dragons’ Den.
As a child she was bright and energetic but often overwhelmed. If she got excited, she was told to pipe down.
She grew up feeling she did not fit in, while the voice in her head, which she calls Karen, replayed every conversation.
Throughout her teens she suffered crushing lows for a week every month. She was prescribed antidepressants, though she says she did not feel depressed, just swamped.
After both her children were born, she was diagnosed with postnatal depression.
In her 40s, she says, she was told three times, on the basis of the same blood tests, that her hormones were normal.
But she is an athlete and she knew something was wrong. ‘I know my body inside out,’ she says.
It was only when she arrived at Tallaght Hospital with signs of a stroke that a hormone specialist, covering the bank holiday, found she did have hormone deficiencies and prescribed HRT.
Then came her own diagnosis: ADHD. At last she had an explanation for so much.
What stays with her is the little girl she once was. ‘That lovely little eight-year-old girl, she wasn’t supported,’ she says. ‘She faced a lot of issues throughout her life, not understanding why.’
What stays with her is the little girl she once was. ‘That lovely little eight-year-old girl, she wasn’t supported,’ she says
For years she had watched other people move through life more easily and concluded the failing was hers. Karen was always there to agree.
Sharon assumed she simply had to try harder so she did, becoming the achiever, the good girl, exhausted by the effort of seeming fine, and carried the sense of falling short into adulthood.
First came relief, then came sadness. Had she known earlier, she says, ‘I would have carried a lot less throughout my life’.
Each of these experiences was different, but the consequences have a familiar ring – women left without answers, learning to live with pain or distress and sometimes beginning to doubt their own judgment.
For some, it took years to find someone who would listen. By then, the cost was measured not only in suffering, but in the lives they might have led.
A survey commissioned by Laya Healthcare found that 56 per cent of women aged 25 to 44 said they had felt dismissed when discussing a health concern with a medical professional.
Pauline now works in advocacy with the Irish Heart Foundation, taking her message to the HSE and to politicians in Leinster House.
‘The patient is the biggest stakeholder in healthcare,’ she says, ‘and sometimes they have the smallest voice.’
- The women interviewed are featured in Health Hysteria: Are Women Being Gaslit? available now on Virgin Media Player
