I joined a ‘clean’ moms group expecting support and sisterhood. Instead I learned the dirty truth that women just HATE to admit

Will I ever learn, when it comes to women?
Apparently not. Because I had nothing but optimism when I joined my first online community for moms.
How nice it will be, I thought, to get advice from some like-minded souls about how I can best look after my children.
The Facebook group was called ‘Crunchy Moms: Natural Living & Clean Products’ and boasted nearly half a million members.
I was expecting sunshine and rainbows. Helpful tips. Wholesome encouragement.
Instead, and somewhat ironically for a group that is supposed to be about ‘low-tox living,’ I found cruelty, viciousness, judgement and all-out bullying at near-radioactive levels.
All I did, in my first post, was to ask how other mothers were reducing their kids’ exposure to plastic at school.
More than 10,000 views and 600 comments later – many mocking me or telling me I’m an awful mom – I have learnt a valuable lesson: nowhere is safe when it comes to female spaces.
When I joined my first online community for moms, I thought how nice it would be to get advice from some like-minded souls about how I can best look after my children
I was expecting sunshine and rainbows. Helpful tips. Wholesome encouragement
In fact, the worst behavior I’ve come across has been in places espousing ‘health’ and ‘wellness.’
It’s a shame, because I’m passionate about low-tox living. I used to be quite the opposite – a heavy-drinking, junk food-consuming anti-hippy. Until I had trouble conceiving my second baby and started researching the links between certain chemicals and poor fertility.
I credit the book It Starts With The Egg, by Rebecca Fett, with getting me pregnant with my daughter and since then have been pretty evangelical about avoiding hormone disrupters including phthalates (chemicals primarily found in plastics) and synthetic fragrances. In short, the sorts of chemicals you’ll find in nearly every standard household product.
The Netflix documentary The Plastic Detox is worth a watch if you want to understand how harmful microplastics are. It’s why I swapped almost every kitchen utensil we use for glass and stainless steel. And it’s why I joined the aforementioned Facebook group.
My very first post was to ask for some advice.
‘I’m pretty sure I’m being overly neurotic,’ I wrote. ‘But having got rid of basically all plastic in the kitchen at home, I went in to eat lunch at my son’s school (cute!) and saw he eats off plastic plates every day there – would it be totally mad and logistically silly to send him in with his own stainless steel one?!’
Within minutes, my phone was lighting up like a Christmas tree – and not in a warm, festive way. I’d inadvertently drawn up battle lines, and two sides emerged. The first consisted of mothers even more anxious than me. They told me I should withdraw my son and homeschool him.
The second, much stranger camp, was made up of women who vehemently disagreed with ‘crunchy living’ and were there merely to troll the group’s members.
I was told I would ruin his life by being a ‘helicopter parent;’ that I was a ‘psycho;’ that my son ‘looked miserable’ in a photo of us together (he’s four and just wasn’t looking at the camera).
I blame myself, but I made the fatal error of engaging with one commenter, who was being particularly vile.
I’m passionate about low-tox living and thought the Facebook group would have sound advice
I was told by someone in the Facebook moms group that I would ruin my son’s life by being a ‘helicopter parent;’ that I was a ‘psycho’
When I clicked on her profile, I laughed out loud upon seeing that her cover image was a Jimi Hendrix quote that reads: ‘When the power of love overcomes the love of power, the world will know peace.’ I could also see she had spent all day commenting on strangers’ posts in a group she clearly had no business being in, for the sheer sport of it.
It’s utterly bizarre. But I shouldn’t be surprised. I spent more than a decade as a travel journalist, reviewing some of the world’s most lavish hotels. The absolute worst of the worst when it came to clientele were always found at the ‘wellness resorts’ or the ‘detox islands.’ Wherever there is yoga, affirmations and sound baths aplenty, there are highly strung, deeply critical women, hiding their disdain – poorly – behind big fake smiles.
Meghan Markle is a poster girl for this. I suffered through the first season of her Netflix show, With Love, Meghan, because I was asked to review it and almost came away with PTSD. I’ve known so many women like her, who sashay through life appearing syrupy sweet but somehow leave behind a trail of enemies in their wake.
And why are mothers so particularly guilty of being mean girls? Actress Ashley Tisdale wrote a piece about it for The Cut earlier this year – on quitting a circle she formerly shared with the likes of Mandy Moore, calling them out for being ‘too high school.’
‘Mom groups can be toxic,’ she later announced on Instagram, ‘you’re allowed to leave.’
I for one am going to take her up on this suggestion and retreat from ‘Crunchy Moms: Natural Living & Clean Products.’
I suspect my life will be an awful lot ‘cleaner’ without an army of opinionated keyboard warriors attacking me when I ask for help.
And fear not, I won’t be sending my son into school with a stainless-steel plate. Clearly, I was having a bad day and lost perspective, just as all mothers do.
But I’d rather care too much about my children than too little and I’d rather deal with my next bad day alone, than share my worries with a girl gang on the internet and expect any kindness in return.
