Reese chocolate heir reveals father’s haunting deathbed confession… and why he is waging war over new recipes

Chocolate heir Brad Reese has opened up about his battle with end-stage cancer and revealed the deeply personal motivation behind his bitter war with Hershey.
In a soul-baring interview with the Daily Mail, the grandson of HB Reese, who created the original peanut butter cup, said he has had 16 brushes with death and been in and out of ICU on a near daily basis.
Reese doubled down on his criticism of Hershey, which he has accused of ruining the taste of some products sold under the iconic orange brand by using cheaper substitutes.
‘They are killing the goose that is laying their golden eggs,’ Reese told the Daily Mail.
He explained how his crusade over alleged recipe changes was spurred on by a dramatic deathbed confession made by his father. Shortly before he died of a heart attack, Brad’s father expressed his regrets about selling the company outside the family.
‘I don’t wanna die because I don’t wanna go to heaven’, Brad says his father told him. Dumbfounded, he asked why and his father said he did not want to be reunited with his own dad because he had ‘double-crossed him.’
‘He made me promise if he gave me my shares I would never sell them.’
Brad now sees it as his duty to put that wrong right by ensuring his grandfather’s legacy prevails.
Brad Reese has doubled down on his criticism of Hershey, which he has accused of ruining the taste of the iconic treat by using cheaper substitutes
Brad Reese, who is the grandson of HB Reese, the inventor of Reese’s peanut butter cups, says he believes his grandfather would be proud of him as fight over the brand’s future
Reese explained how his crusade over alleged recipe changes was spurred on by a dramatic deathbed confession made by his father
‘There’s no amount of money that would send me packing. I’m not doing this for money and I’m not doing this for a position on the board,’ Reese said.
‘I’m doing it because I believe in it, that’s the most important thing. See there’s nothing that the Hershey company can do to financially hurt me.’
But not everyone is convinced. Reese’s own cousin has called his feud against Hershey a ‘nightmare.’
Reese divulged how his unlikely rebellion began on Valentine’s Day, when he opened a bag of Reese’s Mini-Hearts.
Expecting a familiar treat, he found himself so repulsed by the taste, calling it ‘inedible,’ he threw the entire lot away.
For most people, that might have been the end of the matter, but not Reese.
Instead, the Florida retiree published a furious open letter to Todd Scott, Hershey’s manager of corporate brand and editorial, accusing the company of marring the Reese’s name.
His central allegation was that Hershey had been replacing real chocolate in some products with compound chocolate, which uses vegetable oils instead of cocoa butter, while swapping traditional peanut butter for cheaper ‘peanut-butter-style crèmes.’
It was last Valentine’s Day when Reese noticed something was wrong. After lifting a seasonal Reese’s product to his lips he immediately spat it out
His accusation was damning: He claimed Hershey was compromising the quality of Reese’s products by replacing ingredients
To Reese, this was not simply a matter of changing ingredients but a betrayal of the very recipe that had made his family famous. Hershey disputes his characterization of events.
Brad’s grandfather, Harry Burnett Reese, invented the peanut butter cups and built the confectionery business that would eventually be acquired by Hershey in 1963.
Although Reese has never worked for the company, he has spent years proudly defending the family name.
An unmistakable presence in his West Palm Beach retirement community, Reese regularly wears a bright-orange Reese’s T-shirt and strikes up conversations with strangers about his grandfather’s creation.
His open letter post quickly attracted responses from customers ready to revolt and insisted they, too, had noticed a change in their favorite sweet treats.
One 61-year-old consumer said he had eaten Reese’s for as long as he could remember and had repeatedly been told that any difference was down to his changing taste buds.
The complaints soon spread, with the controversy attracting coverage from a widespread number of outlets and even catching the attention of late-night television host Stephen Colbert.
But while consumers rallied behind Reese, the reaction from some members of his own family was considerably less enthusiastic.
Reese said that when shares were passed on through his family they were accompanied by a envelope containing the secret recipe that many have tried to knock-off over the years
The first day of operation for the new HB Reese Candy Company Plant in Hershey, Pennsylvania in 1957
His cousin Becky Hilgers, whose mother was H B Reese’s youngest daughter and the last of his children to die, sent him a particularly furious message.
‘Brad, this is your cousin Becky. You have created a nightmare for our family and the company,’ she wrote. ‘It’s embarrassing to the entire Reese clan. Please stop!’
But Reese refuses to lie low, knowing his time on this earth is nearly up.
Reese revealed that he thinks his grandfather would be extremely proud if he could see him now, adding: ‘He died in West Palm Beach where I live, he died here so I’m going to die here.’
And just four days after his open letter, Hershey responded.
The company maintained that the original Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups recipe had not changed, while acknowledging that adjustments had been made to other products across its range.
Becky Hilgers, Brad’s cousin, responded to his crusade with a fiery counter-narrative
Four days after his original post, Hershey issued a response that appeared to offer a partial defense of its products while acknowledging that some changes had been made
Seasonal confectionery has become a particular point of contention, with manufacturers sometimes using less expensive vegetable fats in limited-edition products created for holidays such as Valentine’s Day, Halloween and Christmas.
The controversy intensified further when videos began circulating on TikTok showing people bending heated Hershey chocolate bars in ways that prompted questions about their ingredients.
At an investor presentation in April, Hershey conceded that it changed the coating on some Reese’s products and promised to return products made with compound chocolate to their previous formulations by 2027, arguing that the changes came before current leadership took over.
Hershey said Brad Reese does not understand how a global candy business operates. The company pointed to its third-quarter results as evidence of how much people still like Reese’s.
But Reese was not satisfied. He began looking beyond the seasonal Reese’s products that had triggered his campaign, scrutinizing supermarket shelves for evidence that other familiar favorites had undergone similar changes.
He pointed to brands including Mr Goodbar, Rolo and Almond Joy, questioning whether cost-cutting had gradually altered the products consumers had trusted for decades.
Still, the biggest question remained unanswered in his eyes – had the original Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups themselves been changed?
Hershey continued to insist that the classic recipe remained untouched.
Seasonal editions, in particular, have attracted scrutiny because manufacturers sometimes use less expensive vegetable fats in products designed for short-lived holiday demand
The classic cups have not changed, the company says. That covers the two-, three- and four-cup packs, king-size, and seasonal shapes like pumpkins.
What did change were the extensions: foil-wrapped molded shapes sold at Valentine’s Day and Easter, Reese’s Minis, Reese’s Thins, and Reese’s Sticks.
Those moved to a cocoa butter equivalent coating, which by law must be labeled ‘chocolate candy’ rather than milk chocolate.
Such coatings swap some or all of the cocoa butter for vegetable oils, and they cost less. Stick formats like Reese’s Take5 and Fast Break have used them for years, a Hershey insider told Fortune.
But Reese, however, had become increasingly skeptical. ‘It’s a brilliant publicity, public relations stunt,’ he said.
‘I haven’t won anything, because it’s total bunk. They’re not going back to the original recipe.’
He told those following his campaign that he had more evidence in his inbox, although he had yet to find the time to organize it all.
‘They could go back to the original recipe in three days,’ he added. ‘They’re just kicking the can down the road, hoping that what I brought up would blow over. It’s a stall.’
And while Hershey insists its original peanut butter cup recipe remains unchanged, Brad Reese is not ready to take the company’s word for it
Hilgers says she and the cousins she’s in touch with ‘are all on the same page.’
‘I don’t think the integrity of the piece of candy has changed so drastically that it doesn’t taste good and people aren’t buying it,’ she previously stated to Fortune.
‘It’s the most recognizable brand that Hershey Company has. We’re still very proud of the piece of candy that our grandfather invented, and we trust the Hershey Company to be the caretaker of the brand.’
Reese lives a quiet life in Century Village, a retirement community for over-55s in West Palm Beach.
He has also battled non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma for more than 15 years, and says he has survived several brushes with death.
It has given him a perspective that makes the sudden media frenzy all the more surreal.
‘I take naps in the morning, naps in the afternoon. This is mad crazy for me,’ he said.
Although he is trying to get to grips with the attention, he has no intention of sacrificing the peaceful retirement he has worked hard to enjoy.
‘I’d do it all over again just because I can,’ he said.
The Daily Mail has reached out to Hershey and Becky Hilgers for comment.
