Second time around: Andrew Shue and Marilee Fiebig marry at his sprawling New Jersey estate weeks after their exes T.J. Holmes and Amy Robach tie the knot

Marilee Fiebig and Andrew Shue finally got their happy ending on Sunday as they tied the knot at their idyllic New Jersey farm, a little over a month after their high-profile exes, T.J. Holmes and Amy Robach, married each other, the Daily Mail can exclusively reveal.

The attorney, 49, said ‘I do’ to the former Melrose Place actor-turned-philanthropist, 59, in a low-key ceremony attended by close family and friends at their secluded 92-acre country estate outside the charming riverfront village of Stockton.

Shue purchased the sprawling property for $3.2 million in April 2023. Boasting a horse farm, two homes dating back as early as the 1700s, rolling pastures, woodland and a stream, the estate provided a picturesque fall backdrop for the couple’s special day.

At just before 2pm on Sunday, the radiant bride left the nearby inn where she had been staying, wearing an elegant floor-length white lace gown with an off-the-shoulder corset-style bodice.

Covering her shoulders with a matching white shawl, a glowing Fiebig wore a chic netted half-veil over her dark tresses, which had been swept into a stylish updo, completing her look with satin block heels.

By her side was her daughter with Holmes, Sabine, 13, who appeared to be a bridesmaid for her mom. She was clutching a white floral bouquet and wearing a floor-length navy satin gown paired with metallic heels.

They were joined by Fiebig’s close friend Lisa Bashishow, a finance executive in the music and entertainment world, who donned a sleeveless satin green midi dress with cream lace detailing and brown cowgirl boots.

The group then boarded a white shuttle bus waiting outside the cottage, before being whisked away to Shue and Fiebig’s bucolic farm for the ceremony.

Andrew’s sister, actress Elisabeth Shue, 63, also celebrated beneath a huge white marquee erected on the grounds especially for the wedding festivities.

Bride and groom appeared to keep it traditional on the eve of their wedding, with Fiebig staying in one of the inn’s luxurious cottages with her teenage daughter.  

Andrew and and Marilee’s nuptials came after their former spouses, Robach, 53, and Holmes, 49, exchanged vows in an intimate ceremony in his home state of Arkansas on September 19.  

Sunday’s wedding capped an unlikely love story that began after Holmes and Robach, then colleagues on Good Morning America’s lunchtime show, GMA3, embarked on a secret romance while still married to Fiebig and Shue.

The foursome had been the closest of friends, dining and cheering each other on at athletic events.

The television hosts lost their jobs after their off-screen trysts were first revealed by the Daily Mail in November 2022.

The couples, both married for over a decade, were said to be separated before the romantic switcheroo was exposed.

Holmes and Fiebig finalized their split in late 2023. Robach agreed a divorce deal with Shue through mediation earlier that year.

Robach and Shue did not have any children together, but previously praised their ‘blended family’ as Shue’s three sons were joined by Robach’s two daughters when they married in 2010.  

In the months that followed, Fiebig and Shue bonded over the very public collapse of their marriages.

Their close bond blossomed into romance, and their relationship was publicly revealed in December 2023.

The couple moved in together in February 2025 before getting engaged this spring.

Announcing their engagement just ten days ago, Shue told People: ‘I don’t know how it happened, but there’s a happy ending.

‘This just happened to be our way of getting to know each other and being able to share ourselves with each other in a time where we both needed a friend.’

Their wedding weekend began on Saturday evening with an intimate sunset cocktail reception at the Woolverton Inn, a boutique hotel and bed-and-breakfast featuring an 18th-century manor and several cottages perched on 300 acres above the Delaware River.

Around 40 family members and close friends gathered in the upstairs section of the inn’s Northridge restaurant, a converted barn that now serves as a fine-dining venue.

Staff were seen making final preparations throughout the afternoon as guests arrived for the celebrations, with one worker seen carrying a large steel drinks bucket filled with beverages.

Exclusive Daily Mail photographs show the lovebirds arriving at the inn earlier in the day unloading suitcases and boxes from Shue’s green Toyota Land Cruiser.

He took the luggage inside the inn, where it is believed the bride-to-be stayed on Saturday night.

Shue left his bride at the inn and returned wearing a navy suit paired with a light blue shirt and lace-up boots, accompanied by his sons Nate, 30, Aidan, 27, and Wyatt, 22, from his previous marriage to Jennifer Hageney.

Meanwhile, the glowing bride greeted guests in a champagne-colored chiffon skirt, cream sleeveless top and matching cover-up.

A beaming Fiebig was snapped welcoming Shue’s actress sister, Elisabeth Shue, 63, who flew in from Los Angeles with her filmmaker husband, Davis Guggenheim, and their daughter.

She was also seen warmly embracing Shue’s brother John, 56, who traveled from Massachusetts for the celebrations.

Elisabeth and Andrew were seen assisting their mother, Anne Harms, who uses a walker, into the venue. 

Their father, James W Shue, who was divorced from their mother when they were young, died in 2013.

Harms previously officiated her son’s wedding to Robach, but it is unclear if she has taken on such a role in his wedding to Fiebig.

Shue was born in Wilmington, Delaware, and became best known for his role as Billy Campbell in the Beverly Hills spinoff, Melrose Place, starring in the drama for six seasons.

He later tried his hand at football, appearing for the Bulawayo Highlanders in the Zimbabwe Premier Soccer League and later made five appearances for LA Galaxy in the 1996-97 season.

Shue then became an entrepreneur and founder of the charity DoSomething and the website CafeMom with his friend Michael Sanchez.

DoSomething aims to inspire and engage young people to create positive change in the world, both online and offline, through various campaigns.

He recently launched The Forum, a nonpartisan civic initiative with political minds from across the ideological spectrum.

In a profile in Town & Country’s November 2026 Philanthropy issue, Shue said the initiative’s end goal is to ‘help set a different tone for 2028 and beyond.’

He told the publication the Forum ‘is currently operating in three states – South Carolina, Nevada and New Hampshire – and it works in phases.’

Shue readily acknowledges he has already encountered naysayers when it comes to his latest project.

 ‘There’s been a few good-luck-with-thats,’ he admitted. ‘But I don’t have time to be cynical. Our leaders have been working in a system that is broken, and now corrupt, and they can’t get out of it.’

‘So we need to get them out of it. We need to flip the script. The American people should be leading, and our leaders should be following.’

‘We’ve been watching the same bad movie every two years, with the same games and the same rabid partisanship in primaries, all for one and a half percent of voters to determine who gets into power…. I’m sure in my bones this is the only way we’re going to get ourselves out of the mess that America is in.’

 The bride’s close-knit family also traveled for the wedding weekend, including her parents, Pauline, 69, and William, 78, as well as her attorney siblings, Chantale, 46, and Jason, 43, and their families.

Fiebig currently serves as legal counsel and a partner at Axis Hats, a luxury arthouse based in New York City.

The 49-year-old was born in the Democratic Republic of Congo, where her mother is from, and met her father when he was serving in the Peace Corps.

The family moved to the United States when Fiebig was five years old ‘because my mom wanted my siblings and me to fully take advantage of the educational opportunities that she didn’t have growing up in Africa,’ she previously told Marie Claire.

Fiebig said her experience moving to the United States inspired her to become an immigration attorney.

The Vanderbilt Law and University of Michigan graduate worked at global law firms in Atlanta, Georgia and New York City.

She later become Chief Diversity Officer at Save the Children, the international humanitarian organization, and worked for the rapper Jay-Z, as Chief of Staff at his entertainment agency RocNation.