Sports

After a rout of Japan the burning question for Gregor Townsend is where are all the Scottish props?

Never a man to mince his words, Japan head coach Eddie Jones offered a typically blunt assessment as he took his seat in the media room at Murrayfield on Saturday afternoon.

Clearing his throat and speaking with his usual candour, Jones was asked for his view on a match which had been a total demolition from start to finish.

‘The scoreboard never lies, mate,’ said Jones. ‘Without making excuses, we’re probably missing around 20 top-line players at the moment.

‘This is a great experience for our players in terms of their development. Nothing teaches you more about Test match rugby than getting your pants pulled down. It hurts and it stays with you.’

Running in 11 tries in total and putting up a cricket score against a depleted Japan side who had also been battered at Twickenham last week, it is difficult to know what Scotland took from this.

Without wishing to be disrespectful, it was as one-sided a game as you could ever wish to see at Test level. But, with regards to all the permutations, there was a bigger picture beyond the game itself.

Scotland head coach Gregor Townsend is light in front-row reinforcements

Liam McConnell scores the second of Scotland's 11 tries in the thumping win over Japan

Liam McConnell scores the second of Scotland’s 11 tries in the thumping win over Japan

Scotland held up their end of the bargain by racking up such a huge score. They gave themselves a fighting chance of finishing third in the northern hemisphere table.

Any sort of South Africa win in Dublin would have seen Gregor Townsend’s men overtake Ireland. Alas, it was not to be.

Scotland will now face Argentina at Twickenham on Sunday as they look to round off the Nations Championship with another win.

After a man-of-the-match performance which saw him score a hat-trick, Liam McConnell has surely given himself a fighting chance of staying in the team.

Of all the fringe players given a chance to impress, McConnell was the one who seized it most emphatically. On both sides of the ball, he was superb.

It is the question of depth which will perhaps occupy Townsend’s thoughts most of all. Or the lack thereof in the front row.

The lack of options beyond Zander Fagerson at tighthead has been a longstanding problem. The drop-off from Fagerson to the rest of the back-ups is steeper than in any other position in the squad.

But there are also now problems at loosehead. Pierre Schoeman and Jamie Bhatti are both nursing injuries.

Nathan McBeth went off at half-time on Saturday with an ankle injury. Rory Sutherland is 32 now and has had his own injury problems in the past.

Simple question: where are all of the Scottish props?

At both tighthead and loosehead, the cupboard is pretty bare in comparison to other positions. The depth just is not there.

Kyle Rowe as another Scotland player to get on the scoresheet against the Cherry Blossoms

Kyle Rowe as another Scotland player to get on the scoresheet against the Cherry Blossoms

Townsend now has an abundance of options in the back row; Rory Darge, Matt Fagerson, Jack Dempsey, Jamie Ritchie, Josh Bayliss, Gregor Brown, Freddy Douglas, Magnus Bradbury, McConnell, Ollie Leatherbarrow.

The depth in that area of the squad is now easily pushing into double digits in terms of players who could start any Test match at any given moment.

The second row is also well-stocked. Likewise the midfield and the back three. Scotland’s depth is strong in so many areas – but the lack of options at prop remains a huge concern.

The scrum has been a weakness now for some time. Given the reliance on them both for their clubs and national team, there is a feeling that Fagerson and Schoeman, the first-choice pairing, could be burnt out.

It is a problem which runs deep into how Scotland are producing young players – and one which will remain after Townsend leaves the scene at the end of next year’s World Cup.

Whilst it might seem strange to focus on the lack of options at prop after an 11-try victory, Townsend himself is now openly speaking about the World Cup.

Everything is now geared towards planning for the tournament next year – and it is the lack of depth at both prop positions which is by far and away the biggest weakness in this squad.

None of this was a concern, of course, to McConnell. He was magnificent and richly deserved his man-of-the-match award after scoring a hat-trick.

‘It was fun to get involved in the attack and to score a few tries,’ said the Edinburgh back-rower. ‘I thought I put myself in a pretty good position coming into the campaign, and then I just wasn’t selected against New Zealand and Australia. That was tough.

‘It made me extra hungry for the Japan game, but I definitely was disappointed over the last couple of weeks.

‘Scoring tries is always good, but there’s other parts of the game as well that the coach will be looking at.

Some of my defence and stuff, so hopefully they’re happy with those aspects as well. It’s not all about the tries. Hopefully I have a chance for next week.’

Darcy Graham grabbed a hat-trick in the comfortable success at Murrayfield

Darcy Graham grabbed a hat-trick in the comfortable success at Murrayfield

Darcy Graham also scored a hat-trick, moving on to 41 in total for Scotland, and extending his lead over Duhan van der Merwe in the all-time list.

Penny for the thoughts of Van der Merwe after this? The squad was heavily rotated for a game against limited opposition at a time when he needs match fitness, and he still couldn’t get near it.

He is so far out of the picture at the moment it is untrue. Will we ever actually see him in a Scotland jersey again? Might he have played his last game?

Certainly, it is difficult to see how he is part of Scotland’s World Cup squad next year. His drop-off has now been too prolonged and too pronounced to be written off as a blip.

Scotland have had a decent year overall. They won three matches in the Six Nations and were in contention to win the title heading into the final weekend in Dublin.

They have then gone on to win four of their six matches in the Nations Championship, with the only defeats coming against South Africa and New Zealand.

Round and round they go under Townsend; scintillating at their best, mediocre at their worst, consistently inconsistent.

The chance to finish the year on a high with a win over Argentina on Sunday would be a decent boost to confidence heading into the Six Nations.

But Townsend could do with finding a few props. Not just for the here and now, but for the World Cup next year. It is a matter of urgency.

  • For more: Elrisala website and for social networking, you can follow us on Facebook
  • Source of information and images “dailymail“

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Back to top button

Discover more from Elrisala

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading