‘Slaughtered like pigs’ for their body parts… while still alive: Organ harvesting doctors are still operating in China despite ‘ban’, experts claim

Chinese security official Zhu Jiabin was nicknamed ‘The Butcher’ for the cold precision with which he slaughtered imprisoned religious minorities by harvesting their organs.
‘After slaughtering and opening up the belly, you just carve out the organs and sell them… It is nothing – just like slaughtering pigs,’ is how he matter-of-factly described how he hacked body parts from prisoners.
‘You come over to shave their hair first and then split open the belly. I would carve out whatever I need. After scooping the organs out, I would sell them,’ the official bragged over the phone.
Zhu was part of a conveyor belt of organ harvesting that saw tens of thousands of prisoners forcefully killed for their organs, fuelling a trade that has generated $1billion annually since 2000.
Many of the victims were followers of Falun Gong spiritual movement and other prisoners of conscience, executed via the transplantation procedure.
China claimed it had banned the macabre practice in 2015 and said it would rely instead on a national organ donation system.
But a new report says over 100 of the doctors and surgeons who were once implicated in the forced organ harvesting of prisoners – which was even performed when they were still alive – are still working across China today.
Rather than facing scrutiny or any known professional consequences, they appear to have spent the intervening decades rising through institutional ranks to become senior leaders in thoracic surgery.
In many cases, the compromised medical professionals identified in the original 2022 study are now senior physicians, transplant centre directors and prominent members of the global transplant community
Members of the Uyghur ethnic minority in a re-education camp in Lop County, Xinjiang, during the mass detention campaign of the Muslim group, which began in 2017
Before banning the practice, China had for years depended on prisoners to supply the vast majority of transplant organs for its population.
Witness testimony indicated that harvesting operations focused on healthy detainees aged 28 or 29, and that after extensive health checks and blood tests, individuals were ‘cross-matched for harvesting’.
A week later, the selected inmates ‘vanished in the middle of the night’, according to Ethan Gutmann of the Victims of Communism Memorial Foundation.
In 2022, the world’s leading medical transplant journal uncovered a disturbing truth underlying China’s transplant industry.
After examining Chinese clinical papers from between 1980 to 2015, the American Journal of Transplantation revealed descriptions of heart or lung procurement indicating that donors were not properly declared brain dead before their vital organs were removed by doctors – thereby violating the Dead Donor Rule.
Today, human rights groups fear that forced organ harvesting from live patients is still going on in the country, despite China’s claims to the contrary.
A November report by the International Coalition to End Transplant Abuse in China (ETAC) shows that doctors whose own published work documents violations of the Dead Donor Rule still hold positions of authority, train young surgeons, co-author international research and appear at global conferences.
In many cases, the compromised medical professionals identified in the original 2022 study by researcher Matthew P Robertson and cardiac transplant surgeon Jacob Lavee, are now senior physicians, transplant centre directors and prominent members of the global transplant community.
According to 71 clinical papers reviewed by Robertson and Lavee, 56 hospitals in 15 provinces were involved in the problematic operations between 1980 and 2015 – whereby donors were killed through organ harvesting procedures.
Over 100 of the compromised doctors were still working at 40 hospitals across 16 provinces in 2025, ETAC has found.
China human rights researcher Sarah Cook, who wrote the ETAC report, told the Daily Mail: ‘The Dead Donor Rule is a foundational principle of transplant medicine to separate transplant surgery from killing.
‘That red line was breached and repeatedly in China, and many of those doctors are still working.
‘The hospitals employing these doctors span more than half of the provinces in China and include leading transplant centres.
‘This is not a fringe problem at a small number of institutions that can be swept under the rug.
‘The past violations of the dead donor rule identified in the 2022 paper form a systemic foundation integral to today’s transplant sector in China.‘
Foreign medical and human rights groups have long condemned China’s organ transplant trade as opaque, profit-driven and unethical.
The findings of the new report call into question government claims of reform, and expose significant risks related to China’s state-sanctioned forced organ harvesting, the killing of prisoners and prisoners of conscience to plug its organ shortfall.
An independent tribunal sitting in London concluded in 2019 that the killing of detainees for organ transplants is continuing, and victims include imprisoned followers of Falun Gong, which draws on Buddhist, Taoist and Confucian concepts.
Persecution of the group began in 1999 after it had attracted tens of millions of followers and came to be seen as a threat to the Communist party.
While Falun Gong practitioners were historically the country’s main source of organs, The China Tribunal found that Uyghur Muslims – an ethnic minority living mainly in Xinjiang – were undergoing medical testing on a scale that could allow them to become an ’organ bank’.
The same tribunal, led by Sir Geoffrey Nice QC, alleged China may be systematically falsifying its organ donation numbers.
It found that as many as 100,000 organ transplants had been carried out in China annually – nearly three times the number that its government reported to the international register.
Sayragul Sauytbay, an ethnic Kazakh physician from Xinjiang, who was previously detained in the province in 2017, has spoken publicly about camp-wide ’health checks’, where prisoners had their blood tested and, depending on their results, were then sorted into groups.
She began to notice that those who were given a pink check mark would soon vanish, concluding it was because of ’organ harvesting’.
The Chinese government has imprisoned more than one million Uyghurs since 2017, and subjected those not detained to intense surveillance, religious restrictions, forced labour, family separations and forced sterilisations, according to the Council on Foreign Relations.
The US declared in 2021 that China’s actions constitute genocide, and a UN report later determined they could amount to crimes against humanity.
Beijing has also been accused of selling organs to wealthy recipients willing to pay the equivalent of tens, if not hundreds, of thousands of pounds.
One kidney transplant patient who spoke at the tribunal testified that he paid RMB350,000 (£38,500) for the organ, then RMB86,000 (£9,800) for the surgery, as well as RMB50,000 (£5,700) as a ’bonus’ to the doctor, which came to a total of RMB486,000 (£53,500).
Kidneys are not even among the most expensive organs.
Jennifer Zeng is a Falun Gong human rights activist who was imprisoned for a year in a female labour camp and fled China in 2001.
In her statement to the tribunal, she said: ’Inmates of the labour camp were not allowed to exchange contact details, so there was no way to trace each other after we were released. When anyone disappeared from the camp, I would assume that she was released and had gone home.
’But in reality that cannot be confirmed, as I had no way to trace others after my release, and I now fear they might have been taken to a hospital and had their organs removed without consent and thus killed in the process.’
Experts raised the alarm last summer after it emerged that the Xinjiang Health Commission, a branch of China’s national health authority, planned to open six new organ transplant medical centres by 2030.
Xinjiang has a much smaller population and lower organ donation rate than other provinces in China, which makes the decision to open more facilities in the region suspicious.
The expansion would bring the total in this northwest region to nine – for a population of only 26 million, ten million of who are Uyghurs. By contrast, Guizhou province in the southwest has a much larger population of 39 million people, but only has three facilities.
Given the history of abuse against the Uyghurs in Xinjiang, there is fear that the new transplant facilities would result in increased forced organ harvesting among the population.
Dong Nianguo, a leading Chinese heart transplant surgeon, at Wuhan Union hospital in 2024. He is a CCP (Chinese Communist Party) member and an author of two clinical papers indicating violations of the Dead Donor Rule
A top transplant doctor in China admitted in 2007 that ’effectively 95 per cent of all organ transplants were from prisoners’, Robertson and Lavee wrote in their landmark study.
They identified 53 recurring authors listed on two or more problematic papers describing violations of the Dead Donor Rule.
These medical professionals are of ’particular concern’, according to ETAC.
That’s because a single clinical paper with a problematic brain death declaration might, in principle, reflect limited involvement in a specific procedure, although it still implies awareness of the practice by co-authors.
But with them appearing on multiple papers, sometimes spanning several years, it suggests their repeated participation in or condoning of procurement practices that violated the Dead Donor Rule.
Thirty-nine of the 53 recurring authors are mostly surgeons and are currently distributed across 13 hospitals located in five provinces and municipalities in eastern and central China, including Hubei, Anhui, Guangdong, Shanghai and Jiangsu.
At the apex of this group are individuals appearing on as many as five or six of the problematic papers.
Many of the recurring authors are now department heads, professors or otherwise among the top transplant surgeons at some of China’s most prominent medical institutions, ETAC said.
Wuhan Union Hospital at Tongji Medical College of Huazhong University of Science and Technology is one of China’s most prominent academic medical centres, and its cardiovascular surgery department has long been among the country’s most active transplant programmes.
Seven named physicians from the department appear across problematic papers published between 1995 and 2005, and almost all remain active in senior roles today, including Dong Nianguo – one of the most prominent heart transplant surgeons in China.
In 2024, Dong hosted the 32nd Annual Meeting of the Asian Society for Cardiovascular and Thoracic Surgery in Wuhan (as rotating president of the association).
That was two years after he was named in the Robertson and Lavee paper as an author on two clinical papers containing evidence of violations of the Dead Donor Rule.
An online invitation letter from Dong for the event cites planned cooperation with the American Association for Thoracic Surgery (AATS) and the European Association for Cardio-Thoracic Surgery (EACTS), while his signature still lists him as an American AATS member.
Hu Bin of Beijing Chaoyang Hospital, another thoracic surgeon identified in the study, has had a career trajectory that is especially noteworthy.
After appearing in a problematic paper published in 2006, he is now Department Director, a graduate supervisor, a CCP member and the Party Branch Secretary of Thoracic Surgery at the hospital.
A July 2024 document lists him as one of 100 ‘outstanding’ CCP members from among health professionals in Beijing.
He is also a council member of the Organ Transplantation Subspecialty Physicians Branch of the Beijing Medical Association, a professional body that is supposed to uphold standards in the field.
He Jianxing, of the First Affiliated Hospital of Guangzhou Medical University, appears as an author on six of the 71 problematic papers, spanning 2006 to 2010.
He is now a leading figure in Chinese thoracic and transplant surgery with an extensive international publication record.
An April 2022 article marking 28 years of his career lists him as a member of the AATS and the European Association for Cardio-Thoracic Surgery (EACTS).
Cheng Xiangyang appeared on four problematic papers between 2006 and 2010.
A March 2026 article on the doctor memberships in the International Association for the Study of Lung Cancer (IASLC), the American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO), and the European Society for Medical Oncology (ESMO).
Cook told the Daily Mail: ‘If the Chinese government wants to show it is serious about reform, then it needs to acknowledge and investigate past ethical violations.
‘Chinese health authorities, transplant professionals and organisations, including the Chinese Medical Association and its Organ Transplantation branch, should acknowledge the findings of the 2022 Robertson-Lavee paper.
‘They should commission a genuinely independent investigation of breaches of the Dead Donor Rule, publish the results, and impose penalties on responsible physicians as outlined in Chinese law, medical association guidelines and international standards.’
Authorship on a peer-reviewed clinical paper may not indicate that all listed co-authors participated in the problematic procedures described, ETAC said.
Nevertheless, being listed as an author represents a ‘professional endorsement of its contents’, the report said.
‘At a minimum, named authors were aware of and publicly associated themselves with the procurement practices described.
‘Whether every author was physically present at every procedure, the association with a paper describing problematic brain death declarations is itself a serious breach of professional ethics.
‘Chinese physicians documented in a peer-reviewed study to have violated the Dead Donor Rule, or condoned its violation, remain active in the medical system,’ it concluded.
ETAC has called on international governments to make visa decisions that allow for denial of entry to foreign nationals who engaged in organ trafficking or coerced transplantation.
The group said foreign governments should also impose targeted sanctions, including asset freezes, on Chinese government officials and other individuals for whom there is credible evidence of authorising, directing, facilitating, participating in or knowingly enabling forced organ harvesting or associated organ trafficking in China.
Beijing has consistently insisted it adheres to international medical standards requiring organ donations be made by consent and without any financial incentive.
It has said international allegations of impropriety are politically motivated and false.
