Health and Wellness

Can hot chocolate EVER be good for you? We reveal the High Street favourites that are actually a health-conscious choice – as analysis finds some contain the same amount of sugar as SEVEN Krispy Kremes in a single cup

Few things are as comforting as a warming cup of hot chocolate as the weather turns and the nights draw in. 

But with all the promise of the festive season comes gloom-laden warnings that some of our favourite winter pick-me-ups are packed with enough sugar and saturated fat to wreck our teeth, expand our waistlines and even send us to an early grave. 

According to a new analysis, some popular high-street hot chocolates contain more than double an adult’s recommended daily sugar intake in a single cup – while others have enough cream to deliver more than half a day’s saturated fat allowance.

Starbucks’ seasonal Peppermint White Hot Chocolate topped the list, containing a staggering 73.6g of sugar, the equivalent of around 17 teaspoons and more sugar than seven Krispy Kreme Original Glazed doughnuts.  

But the question remains: Is there such thing as a healthy hot chocolate? 

According to registered nutritionist Rob Hobson, the surprising answer is yes. 

Starbucks’ seasonal Peppermint White Hot Chocolate can contain up to 73.6g of sugar – more than five Krispy Kreme Original Glazed doughnuts

That’s because cocoa itself contains naturally occurring plant compounds called flavanols that have been linked to improved blood flow and better heart health, while also providing minerals including magnesium and iron. 

‘If you’re looking for the healthiest hot chocolate possible, I’d recommend making it yourself, with unsweetened cocoa powder, honey and maybe a pinch of chili,’ Hobson said. 

‘That way, you’re getting the benefits of cocoa without all the added sugar and saturated fat that can come with cream-laden coffee shop versions.’ 

But while the healthiest version may be the simplest, there are some high street options that come far closer to ideal than others. 

What is actually in hot chocolate?    

At its most basic, hot chocolate powder is just cocoa and sugar. 

Traditional hot chocolate, meanwhile, is made by melting chocolate solids into warm milk, giving it a richer flavour and silkier texture. 

Cheaper versions often contain relatively little cocoa, sometimes as little as 20 per cent, while premium brands tend to contain far higher levels, delivering a stronger chocolate flavour and potentially more of cocoa’s beneficial compounds. 

But it quickly gets more complicated. 

Many instant hot chocolate powders contain a long list of additives including milk powders, palm oil, flavourings and emulsifiers.

Seasonal varieties may even include festive flavourings from gingerbread to peppermint. 

While cocoa itself contains compounds linked to heart health, nutritionists warn that these benefits can be undermined by the high sugar and fat content found in many popular products. 

‘My advice would be to check the ingredients list and, if you want more control over the sugar content, make your own using unsweetened cocoa powder and add a little honey to taste,’ Hobson said. 

What’s the healthiest high street hot chocolate? 

Experts say cocoa content is often more important than calorie count alone when it comes to selecting a healthier hot chocolate.

Generally speaking, products containing more cocoa provide higher levels of beneficial plant compounds, while shorter ingredient lists often indicate less processing.

But many drinks sold on Britain’s high streets are a long way from a simple blend of cocoa and milk.

MyFitnessPal’s analysis of drinks from seven popular retailers found sugar levels varied enormously between festive specials and classic hot chocolates.

Starbucks’ seasonal Peppermint White Hot Chocolate topped the list with 73.6g of sugar per drink, the equivalent of around 17 teaspoons.

Its classic hot chocolate also contained more than 34g of sugar per serving, meaning one cup alone exceeds an adult’s recommended daily limit.

Costa’s standard hot chocolate contained 51g of sugar and 409 calories per serving, almost twice as much sugar as Gail’s milk hot chocolate.

Greggs’ large hot chocolate and McDonald’s version of the winter favourite also sailed past the NHS recommendation of 30g of free sugar a day, containing more than 40g before any toppings were added.

‘Even a classic hot chocolate can contain more than ten teaspoons of sugar, which might surprise people,’ Hobson said.

‘You don’t need lots of fancy syrups and toppings for these drinks to contain quite a bit of sugar. Choosing a smaller serving is probably the simplest way to reduce it.’

However, sugar does not tell the whole story.

Caffè Nero’s Luxury Hot Chocolate was among the lower-sugar options, containing 30g per serving (7.5 teaspoons).

However, it was also one of the highest in calories and fat, packing almost 27g of fat in a single cup, thanks largely to its generous helping of cream.

More than half of that comes from saturated fat, which can raise levels of LDL, or ‘bad’, cholesterol, increasing the risk of heart disease and stroke.

‘It’s a good reminder that looking at sugar alone doesn’t always give you the full picture,’ Hobson said. ‘I’d enjoy this as an occasional treat rather than a regular drink.’

For those ordering on the high street, drinks from Knoops are likely to be among the healthier options available.

Unlike many coffee shop creations pre-loaded with syrups, sauces and whipped cream, customers can choose both the cocoa percentage and sweetness level.

Its 100 per cent cacao drink contains no added sugar in the chocolate itself, while also providing magnesium, iron and the naturally occurring compounds found in cocoa solids.

Among supermarket options, Green & Black’s Organic Hot Chocolate stood out for its use of real cocoa and chocolate.

Research has linked cocoa-rich foods with improved cardiovascular health, while studies have also suggested dark chocolate may have mood-boosting effects.

The downside is that it remains relatively high in sugar, containing 23g per serving (nearly six teaspoons) when prepared with semi-skimmed milk.

At the other end of the scale, Options Belgian Hot Chocolate is one of the lightest choices available, containing just a teaspoon and a half of sugar and around 40 calories per mug, when made with water.

Caffe Nero's Luxury Hot Chocolate has one of the lowest sugar contents on the list

Caffe Nero’s Luxury Hot Chocolate has one of the lowest sugar contents on the list

However, it relies on sweeteners including sucralose and acesulfame K to achieve its sweetness.

While both have been approved as safe by regulators, some experts suggest limiting their intake.

Is 100 per cent dark chocolate really better for you? 

If you can’t stomach chocolate darker than Cadbury’s classic Dairy Milk, the 100 per cent cacao drinks appearing on supermarket shelves in recent years may feel firmly out of reach.  

But when it comes to nutrition, experts generally agree that darker is better.  

That’s because dark chocolate contains a higher proportion of cocoa solids, which provide naturally occurring compounds called flavanols, which give the drink its bitter taste.

These antioxidants stimulate the production of nitric oxide which helps support normal blood flow, reducing the risk of heart disease. 

‘The potential health benefits come from the cocoa solids, so generally speaking the higher the cocoa content, the better. The key is finding the balance between enjoying the drink and not loading it up with lots of added sugar. Cacao also provides minerals including magnesium and iron,’ Hobson added.

In fact, 100g of unsweetened cocoa contains almost an entire day’s recommended intake of iron and more than 130 per cent of the daily recommendation for magnesium, although only a small amount would typically be used in a mug of hot chocolate.

And while 100 per cent cocoa powder contains around 50 calories more per 100g than milk chocolate, it is also lower in sugar and contains around double the protein – making for a more satiating afternoon pick me up. 

Should you add milk or water?  

It’s a debate that has divided hot chocolate drinkers for years.

The more calorie-conscious among us may opt to make their drinks with water. 

But from a nutritional perspective, Hobson says full-fat dairy milk may be the ‘healthiest’ option. 

Studies have shown that, despite its higher saturated fat content, consuming full-fat dairy makes little difference to weight gain, but can result in lower blood pressure and a boost in bone-building calcium, protein and vitamin D. 

Whole milk also contains beneficial vitamins A, D, E and K, which low fat versions and water don’t have. 

Semi-skimmed milk is not necessarily a poor choice either, given the 240mg of bone-boosting calcium in a small glass. 

However, the lack of fat means you’ll miss out on a significant chunk of the healthful vitamins in the full-fat version if you’re using a chocolate powder low in cocoa solids. 

Water, meanwhile, produces a lower-calorie drink but provides none of these additional nutrients.

For those avoiding dairy, Hobson recommends fortified plant-based alternatives such as almond, oat or soy milk – which offers a comparable amount of protein alongside added calcium.

  • For more: Elrisala website and for social networking, you can follow us on Facebook
  • Source of information and images “dailymail“

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Back to top button

Discover more from Elrisala

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading