Why so many women look older than their years? Their make-up! Expert SARAH CREAL can help if you take her VERY honest advice

Since I was 23, I’ve developed beauty products. I began my career working on the Clinique counter before moving into product development.
I’ve worked with everyone from Donna Karan and Tom Ford to Victoria Beckham, whose make-up brand I co-founded.
But I realised when I hit 50 that I was no longer creating products for women my age.
I remember developing a blush stick and saying the formula wasn’t quite right. My entire team of twentysomethings insisted it was perfect, but when I applied it, it didn’t glide on the way it ought to and needed more glow.
I found myself having to adapt my own formulas, because spectacular products I had made were no longer working for me. I helped to create Tom Ford’s original Shade and Illuminate palette, but as I got older I found I needed a softer contour that leans more bronze than grey.
Since she was 23, Sarah Creal has been developing beauty products. She began her career working on the Clinique counter before moving into product development
But what really changed everything was a dream I had in December 2022, aged 53. I woke up thinking: ‘Why is no one talking to me in beauty? Why is no one formulating for me, educating me about what’s happening with my skin and why things aren’t working for me any more? And most importantly, why is no one reflecting me back to me in a way that I think is cool?’
So I decided to create my own brand, specifically for women over 40, which launched in the US two years ago and has just landed in the UK. Over the past 30 years, I’ve learned a lot about cosmetics, ageing and how to make make-up work for you as you get older. Here are some of my top tips.
Adapt to your skin’s changing texture
The Firm Offer Ultimate Eye Cream is designed specifically for skin aged 40 and over (£75.00)
Your skin’s moisture barrier is not what it used to be. It was like a brick wall locking in hydration. Now that wall is missing a lot of bricks, so you need to add moisture back, then seal it up every day using ingredients such as hyaluronic acid, squalene and glycerin.
Then there’s density. You’ve lost collagen and elastin, so features will start to sag and soften. Everything needs to change – from the way you apply your make-up to the products you’re using.
To counter this, increase your face’s dimensionality – define your eyes and brows, use bronzer and blush to give your cheeks shape, and use creamy formulas so things don’t look flat.
Layer multiple products
Sarah Creal’s Brilliant Repair Shield sunscreen. The 3-in-1 Illuminating SPF50 Skin Tint combines broad-spectrum sun protection with a radiant tint and antioxidant skincare (£50.00)
When I say you need to use more make-up, the idea is not to plaster on a thick coat of foundation to hide sunspots and hyper- pigmentation.
Instead, apply thin layers of hard-working products. Layer hydration with sun and pollution protection – I have a product called Brilliant Repair Shield (£50), which is an illuminating SPF 50 skin tint that gives antioxidant protection and a glowy base.
Then you can spot-apply a concealer or complexion enhancer where you need it, blend it with a small brush so you don’t disturb the tint and you’ll have a radiant, even complexion.
Stop using products from your 20s
What worked in your 20s is unlikely to work in your 50s – both in terms of products and application. You need to refresh your products – and refresh your knowledge of how to put them on.
For example, when you’re young, you can put contour in the hollows of your cheeks and place a very obvious highlighter on your cheekbones.
At my age, if I do that, I look really hollow – and a tad crazy.
Now, I use the contour higher up on my cheek and a more subtle highlighter goes at the very, very top of my cheekbone, much closer to my eye. The overall effect is lifting rather than hollowing.
Look for lighter formulas
Sarah Creal’s Beauty Face Flex Concealer & Complexion Enhancer is a medium-coverage hybrid concealer and foundation which hydrates the skin (£44.00)
When you’re formulating products for women in their 20s and 30s, their skin is like a rubber mat – strong and bouncy. But for somebody my age, it’s like tissue paper.
With age, we lose fat in the face, as well as the proteins that keep skin firm and bouncy, and it tends to be drier and will have more fine lines. Moisturising helps to some extent and will ease the way make-up goes on, but really everything needs to have a lighter viscosity. It must be thinner, but that doesn’t mean it has to have less coverage.
I’ll take a base formula that is thin and put pigments in it that are treated so they glide over the skin, giving coverage without being thick and cakey.
Don’t ‘quiet quit’ wearing mascara
My first seven products came from doing a survey of 2,000 women over 40 about what make-up works for them.
It transpired that, at around the age of 55, women were quiet-quitting mascara as it was ending up under their eyes.
I realised most of them were using a mascara they had loved for years, but had added an eye cream for fine lines, then probably added a moisturising concealer.
The result is two oily or moisturising products acting as make-up remover. You need an eye cream that penetrates the skin and a concealer that contains both moisture that sinks into the skin and a polymer that sits on top to protect your mascara.
That’s what I’ve tried to create with Firm Offer Eye Cream (£75) and Face Flex Concealer (£44). A tubing mascara that can be removed with warm water rather than oil will also help.
