‘Stay away’ from the hospital: What Byron Bay doula told mums… before she allegedly left newborn baby to die while she set up a jumping castle after birth with no medical staff present

A Byron Bay doula who allegedly left a critically ill newborn to go and set up an inflatable jumping castle had accused the medical industry of profiting off parents’ fears just months prior to the baby’s death.
Amy Lou Smith, who is a birthing doula from the NSW Northern Rivers, made headlines this week after she appeared at a coronial inquest into the deaths of four babies born in free births or home births in the region between 2022 and 2024.
Free births, or unassisted births, are an intentional choice to give birth at home without a registered midwife or doctor present, and often take place alone or with partners, family, doulas, or ‘birth keepers’ like Ms Smith.
The inquest was told Ms Smith was involved in the home birth of one of the four children on August 16, 2024 and was paid $2,000 by his parents to attend the birth and help ‘keep mum and baby safe’.
Tragically, the child, referred to at the inquest as Baby DH, lived for just over eight hours and was later found to have been born with a complex heart abnormality.
Following his death, the parents of Baby DH told police he had been born purple and with floppy limbs, and was experiencing trouble breathing and would not feed. They also reported seeing strange bumps on his chest and tailbone.
The parents said their concerns were downplayed by Ms Smith on at least five occasions, before she left their home to set up an inflatable jumping castle for her son’s birthday party.
Shortly after, Baby DH stopped breathing and his parents called Triple Zero. He was transported via ambulance to Byron Bay Hospital where he was pronounced dead.
Byron Bay doula Amy Lou Smith allegedly left a critically ill newborn to go and set up an inflatable jumping castle for her son’s birthday party
The first-time parents were repeatedly assured nothing was wrong by Ms Smith (pictured with her partner Jeff Kessel)
While appearing at the inquest on Wednesday, Ms Smith said the couple was happy for her to leave their home.
‘Everything felt like it was okay,’ she told the court. ‘I believed if they had real concerns, that they would call an ambulance and not be texting a non medically trained doula.’
In a podcast interview published ten months before the incident, Ms Smith said her main priority at work is to ‘protect the energy’ of the birthing space, while accusing the medical system of profiting off the back of parents’ fears.
‘I’ve heard so many stories about the fear-mongering and the way staff make people think their bodies don’t work and their baby will die,’ Ms Smith told the Birthspace Brotherhood podcast.
‘When really, they are just adhering to hospital policy or just doing the more convenient option for them… ultimately birth belongs in the hands of women, families and the community.
‘It’s not until birth is back where it belongs that we’ll see less cases of birth trauma. The hospital is working exactly as it’s meant to – it’s a fact, it’s a business, and so normalised, it’s horrible.’
She also described herself in the podcast as a ‘birth-keeper’ whose role is not to ‘see if anything is going wrong’.
It comes after the court heard on Wednesday that the parents of Baby DH hired Ms Smith after learning she specialised in spotting ‘warning signs’ that may indicate an emergency requiring hospitalisation.
On a 2022 podcast, Ms Smith advised parents to ‘stay away’ from the hospital if they can – this podcast was played at the hearing
Ms Smith, who is not medically trained, reportedly told the first-time parents that irregular breathing was common in newborns and that it made Baby DH make ‘cute little noises’.
She is also said to have reassured the parents that ‘some babies take time to land’.
‘Time and time again we looked to her for advice and guidance,’ the baby’s father said. ‘We trusted her because of her long-time experience with birthing.’
Ms Smith denied her comments amounted to clinical advice and told the inquest that a doula’s role was emotional support.
She also said she had only attended six births without a midwife present, prior to the birth of Baby DH.
A video of another podcast featuring Ms Smith was played to the courtroom in which she criticised unnecessary medical intervention to start babies breathing, and said ‘birth is big business, funded by big pharma.’
She also claimed some babies needed ‘a minute or two’ to start breathing and said: ‘If you can, stay away from hospital.’
Those claims were later dismissed by experts at the inquest, with Dr Alison Teate, the president of the Australian College of Midwives, stating the ‘business of birth’ is being taken over by surgery, not by organisations that sell medications.’
The court heard that the birthing mother was not opposed to emergency intervention, including a caesarean section if needed (stock image)
When asked on her thoughts on Ms Smith spreading medically inaccurate information via the podcast, Dr Teate described the question as ‘awkward.
‘The concerning thing is Amy didn’t understand what the benefit of having skillful midwifery care was about. She didn’t understand that intervention, when used wisely, (is) appropriate,’ Dr Teate said.
Professor of Midwifery Hannah Dahlen said Ms Smith’s comments were ‘dangerous’.
‘I think humans should be able to have conversations. The difference (is) she was doing this under her title as a birth worker… it was giving her a level of authority,’ she said.
The inquest heard Ms Smith has not worked as a doula since the death of Baby DH.
She shares three children with her partner Jeff Kessel, who works as a Lecturer at SAE University College and as a DJ at Byron Bay FM.
The inquest also heard from a midwife who was involved in the home birth of twins in December 2022, which resulted in the tragic death of one of the babies.
The newborn, known as Baby B, was just days old when her condition deteriorated and she was rushed to Scone Hospital, where, despite extensive resuscitation efforts, Baby B died.
The evidence forms part of an ongoing coronial inquest at Lismore Court House (pictured) into the deaths of four babies born in free births or home births in the NSW Northern Rivers region between 2022 and 2024
Tests later revealed Baby B had neonatal ammonia and sepsis after contracting group B streptococcal disease, which is a serious bacterial infection. The other twin was also found to be unwell but survived the infection.
The court heard the mother had ‘intentionally and consistently’ sought to birth her babies at home, despite repeated concerns from health staff, paramedics and local police that she give birth in hospital.
‘She had a very strong (belief) about her body’s ability to birth her two babies and had a very strong faith background,’ the woman’s midwife told the inquest.
‘She had built her home and prepared her home for her children. She felt that was the safest place for her to be.’
The woman was supported in the birth by four midwives.
The inquest continues.
Do you know more? Email tips@dailymail.com.au
